Sanitarium Peanut Butter Natural Smooth
2.4 from 25 star ratings
40% would add to their trolley
  • oily sloppy mess

    0.5 out of 5

    I bought this from Coles, in lockdown, cant get my regular one, What an oily sloppy disappointing mess, you can pour it out of the jar, in fact it spilt, its so sloppy……is it mean to be like this? Never had a peanut butter that is almost liquid before, not a fan.

  • Sanitarium Peanut Butter Natural Smooth

    1.5 out of 5

    Unfortunately I was disappointed in this Peanut Butter I like to spread it on toast and I found it to be hard to spread and after some time there was an oil content in the jar.

  • Oily Bland Yuck

    1.5 out of 5

    It doesn’t even taste like peanut butter, more like cardboard. My daughter hates it too. All the oil sits on top and doesn’t mix in well. All in all, a terrible product.

  • No thanks

    2 out of 5

    This is what happens when I try and go healthy, the world conspires against me and my natural peanut butter seperates and tastes unpleasant. Not a fan!

  • Okay

    3 out of 5

    For the price this one is okay. I do prefer to buy 100% nuts and from Aussie nuts so I usually choose bega which has more flavor just more expensive

  • Not Australian peanuts

    0.5 out of 5

    Very disapointed to read LESS THAN 10% Australian product but shows the Aussie Made Kangaroo. ! What has happened to Sanitarium. Sorry Woolies Im taking it back !

  • Nutty

    2 out of 5

    Not terrible but my peanut butter lovers stopped eating peanut butter until I changed brands and I grew to dread making sandwhiches because it’s a bit harder to spread. Tried mixing the oil in or just using as is and neither way seems to make it better. Taste was ok, just a bit dry and clumpy.

  • Not great

    2.5 out of 5

    Like others, I had purchased to try to reduce my salt/sugar intake however found it hard to mix together as the oil sat on the top. It wasn’t as tasty as others either.

  • crunchy is better

    1 out of 5

    I like Sanitarium products however crunchy peanut butter is better and peanut butters that are 100 percent peanut and don’t have added sugars and salt.


    0.5 out of 5

    Front label says Australian Made BUT back label says 0 % Australian Content. Peanuts are from overseas, not from Australia..quite mis-leading to me.

  • Not too bad but quite hard

    3 out of 5

    Bought this to try and be healthy but found that it was quite hard to spread.
    The oil settled on the to l top and it was so hard to mix into the actual peanut butter itself.
    The taste wasn’t so bad but because the oil didn’t mix in properly it was quite dry towards the end.

  • Generic brand is better

    2 out of 5

    When I have a smoothie I’ll place a heaped spoon of peanut butter in it
    For some reason all I could taste was the taste of this peanut butter
    The taste was not satisfying
    And it was just not pleasantly nice the after taste
    The cost of the product is what is appealing reason for my purchase

  • The only one I'll buy

    5 out of 5

    This is 100% peanuts which is the way it should be. Yes you have to stir it before using it because the oil separates(and because they don’t put awful things in there to keep it stable), but that is no hardship.

  • O.K

    2 out of 5

    Yes it is the healthier alternative however to me it was way too hard to spread on toast and on bread it was even harder to spread

  • Definitely not for me

    0.5 out of 5

    I found it to be awful, really oily,i stirred in the oil on the top that was a mistake. I just didn\’t like the taste or consistency. Tossed it in the bin

  • definitely

    5 out of 5

    peanut butter is a must have in my life. I always buy different peanut butter brand, I read percentage of peanuts and then buy the product. I have tried Sanitarium and it is very yummy and pure. will definitely add this in my trolley and would highly recommend it to other mums.

  • Very Good !

    4 out of 5

    Sanitarium natural smooth peanut butter is a good spread we enjoy for breakfast,an excellent brand that l trust to buy and most importantly it is very good!

  • ????

    0.5 out of 5

    Yuck yuck yuck yuck. It’s really not a good peanut butter. It’s sloppy and just doesn’t taste great. Even my 18 month old daughter hated it and she loves peanut butter!

  • Sanitarium

    5 out of 5

    We eat and use a lot of peanut butter in recipes and in cooking and Sanitarium peanut butter is a good peanut butter to use for cooking my recipes.

  • The most sloppy peanut butter ever.

    0.5 out of 5

    I’m sorry Sanitarium but this is a big fail in my book. Your instructions state that one can stir the oil in but there was no stiff PB to stir into. Very disappointed – your standards were so high and this is not up to them. PB that pours out of the jar after stirring for a whole minute is not up to par.
    It is a peanut sauce, not butter.

  • Like that it's just nuts

    5 out of 5

    This product just goes to show you don’t need to add heaps of oil, salt and sugar to peanuts to make a delicious peanut butter

  • Nice

    3 out of 5

    This natural peanut butter is nice. The flavour is good and it’s really easy to spread. I more of a crunchy fan but the kids like this one.

  • LOve it

    3.5 out of 5

    I’ve been eating this peanut butter for a few years and really like the taste and texture of it. I love it and so do my kids!

  • Look elsewhere

    0.5 out of 5

    There are so many nut butters on the shelves. I look for no salt, no sugar. Easily found and price competitive. Taste better and are a healthier alterative.

  • Natural nutty goodness

    5 out of 5

    This product is 100% peanuts – meaning there is no guilt to eating this yummy spread! It tastes delicious (although perhaps is not as flavorsome as the butters which add oil) and spreads easily. Would recommend if you’re looking for a healthier option

Rate this product
Your Rating

Please ensure you have first-hand experience of this product before you rate it — it's important all ratings are genuine & honest.

Enter 25 more words to earn MoM rewards points for this rating. This review is eligible for MoM reward points!
Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating