Imitation Subway Cookies - Real Recipes from Mums

Serves 15
Makes 30
90 minutes
Difficulty Easy
8 Ingredients
Love

A great recipe for the adults (and kids of course). Guaranteed to be gone instantly.

Ingredients (serves 15 | makes 30 cookies)

2 cups self raising flour
170g melted butter
185g brown sugar
110g white sugar
1 tablespoon vanilla essence
1 egg
1 egg yolk
2 cups dark Nestlé Choc Bits

Method

Preheat oven to 165°C . Line trays with baking paper
Sift flour and set aside
In a bowl, cream together the melted butter, brown sugar and white sugar until well blended. Beat in the vanilla, egg and egg yolk Until light and creamy.
mix in thwthe sifted ingredients until just blended
Stir in the Choc Bits by hand using a wooden spoon. Drop big round tablespoons of dough onto prepared cookie trays (leave room for spreading)
Bake for 15-17 minutes in the preheated oven or until the edges are lightly toasted. Cool on baking sheets for a few minutes before trandfering to wire racks to cool completely.

Notes... - I like to make a batch, roll it into a log and place in the freezer and quick and easy go to cookie dough. - You can also leave over a few tablespoons of the Choc Bits to place ontop of your cookies while they are cooling down. This is great for presentation.

45 Comments

- - mom418449 said
  - 07 Jul 2020
    4:59 pm
These look chewy and yummy like the real subway cookies – thanks for sharing. Yum!

- - mom207052 said
  - 11 Apr 2020
    5:23 pm
Oh wow, will definitely try these. I love Subway cookies!

- - rachelvk said
  - 06 Apr 2020
    7:08 pm
Love a soft and gooey cookie!
- rachelvk replied
  
  08 Apr 2020 , 1:03 pm
  I wonder how close these are to the Subway version!
- - mom19782016 said
  - 05 Apr 2020
    6:50 am
Ooh, I like the ingredients – they sound like they would turn out super soft!

- - Mummyofone77 said
  - 01 Apr 2020
    4:08 am
Mm these look yummy and gooey

- - sars_angelchik said
  - 14 Jun 2018
    10:10 am
You had me at chocolate!

- - mom101628 said
  - 04 Jan 2018
    9:47 pm
Love the idea of keeping the mixture in the freezer so you don’t have to cook all at once. Must try this.

- - dearkaren97 said
  - 02 Feb 2017
    2:37 am
Have to give it a try, yummy

- - youngoldlady said
  - 25 Oct 2016
    12:12 am
Thank you for this, very handy as the family love these.

- - mom111059 said
  - 29 Sep 2016
    9:13 pm
Now that looks interesting. Thanks for sharing your yummy recipe.

- - mom19782016 said
  - 21 Jan 2016
    1:12 pm
These wouldn’t last long in our house!

- - mom152736 said
  - 14 Oct 2015
    4:24 pm
amazing…sure will be gone quick ! delicious !

- - jodiev1980 said
  - 30 Sep 2015
    11:03 pm
I love Subway cookies will be trying this

- - jellybean01 said
  - 27 Sep 2015
    7:56 am
yummo! love subways cookies thanks for sharing

- - mom109009 said
  - 10 Sep 2015
    11:03 pm
Yum yum yum.