Hello!

9 Answers

I would like to know how you Mummies punish your children.

I keep being told I’m easy going on my daughter. But I’m just frightened of scaring or upsetting her. She died when she was 2 days old which is one reason I hold her a lot closer than others would perhaps. But I also lived with an abusive Father and don’t want my daughter to EVER live through that kind of thing.

She is VERY naughty though. She refuses to listen to a word I say. If I do not give in and give her what she wants, she screams, hits, kicks, bites, throws things and even hurts her Nanna. I don’t know what to do. I’ve tried talking firmly, smacking on the bum, yelling, taking toys away, sitting her in time out, no tv. I won’t smack hard at all and thats where people are telling me i’m doing wrong. I only give a light tap, literally nothing at all…

I don’t know what else to do to get her attention and understand she has to listen to Mummy.  I even get down to her level and attempt to talk things through with her. But she just slaps me in the face or turns away and wont listen.

(She is ADHD and suspected Aspergers)


Posted by christie_miller, 8th July 2014


Want more real mum questions sent to you?


You'll need to check this email to complete your signup.

Topics

Ask your question
  • Personally I believe in positive and negative reinforcement of certain behaviours. The best way to reduce negative behaviour is by first finding out why she behaves that way and be proactive not reactive (with other words prevent it) as you can see behaviour as a form of communication. Very important to praise every positive behaviour and give it attention and when possible ignore negative behaviour.
    When you feel it grows above your head I would try and get a referral for a psychologist.


  • I see this was posted in 2014, I wonder how you are going now? Perhaps her therapist (assuming she has one due to her medical conditions) might help. As parents it is hard to not react to the behaviour and work out why they are doing something which may be an unmet need or not being able to communicate clearly


  • time in, or time out. explain why


  • Are you seeing someone about her ADHD and suspected aspergers? Ask them to recommend how to manage and hep her behaviour, my son has ADHD and it was very tough going (he’s now 18). He still defies me even now, I was too lenient on him but did what I could at the time to survive. Specialists did help


  • I think you’re doing everything right. Being a parent is one if the hardest jobs


  • I think you are doing everything perfectly. You just have to be consistent.


  • You have to be incredibly firm, strong, and consistent. Your little one must learn boundaries, even children with much more profound problems than your daughter learn boundaries. It is not easy and you and your daughter will need all the love and support of your family and Friends . You may even need to enlist the guidance of some sort of child behavioral specialist to give you a starting point. Most of all you must keep letting your daughter feel your love.


  • Oh getting down to her level is perfect. I have a “thinking chair” I put in the laundry so it isn’t near the TV. And I ask my daughter to sit on the chair and think about what she is done and to come out to say sorry etc….. my daughter is only 2 and I only have to say, “hold on, you are close to going on the thinking chair” and her behavior settles down. Hopefully this might help, but I know it can be tough. I too get told I am too soft but sometimes they can just be too cute!


  • Sounds like you are being a great mum.
    She does need some discipline but just be consistent and don’t give in once you start see it through,
    but also pick your battles, think is this really worth a tantrum over?


Post you answer
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

What is your answer to that question?
Would you like to include a photo?
No picture uploaded yet.
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.
Your MoM account


Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your answer and join MoM:

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join