Hello!

67 Answers

I am curious as to what other parents think about this topic as it has been on the news & in newspapers for the last few days. It is banned in 32 countries at the moment. I was raised and got smacked & it has never affected me years later. I have however seen parents at shopping centres taking a smack way too far!


Posted anonymously, 17th December 2013


Want more real mum questions sent to you?


You'll need to check this email to complete your signup.
Ask your question
  • I think it is best to avoid smacking. It rarely has benefits and can harm significantly.


  • We don’t smack our children, never have. In theory I think there may be occasions when it’s necessary (eg a very small child about to do something dangerous), but I’ve never had it happen with my own.


  • I grew up in an era where you would get smacked and it did me no harm, as long as parents explain why they are being smacked. If children are not disciplined they grow up to be adults that have no discipline.


  • I was never smacked as a child. I never liked smacking my kids, I think there are other ways to get your point across, I don’t like it. I think some take it too far. And yet, I have smacked my kids, not proud of it but it’s happened


  • I think there is a huge difference between a smack on the bum to say that behaviour is not acceptable, and full on child abuse smacking.
    I smack my children on the bum as a last resort for discipline. However, 9 times out of 10 it doesn’t hurt them and they continue being obnoxious anyway.
    I would never smack any other part of their body though and my intention is never to hurt, only to make a point.
    As a child, I received many smacks, belts, a hairbrush on the bum, legs, arms, and it never did any damage to me, nor do I resent my parents for it. I think it taught me respect and to know when enough is enough.


  • This old debate. I don’t regularly smack my daughter, I can honestly say in 5 years she’s probably had 10 smacks. Last time she was naughty I cut out her canteen money and lunches and that worked really well. I was smacked and it didn’t make me violent. It just taught me a lesson.


  • I occassionally smack my children. Not hard and as a final resort.
    I find that I smacked more when tey were younger. My boy is now 9 and I prefer to discuss things with him, so that he better understands why something has upset me.
    My two year old, smacking would work to begin with, but then she started smacking us back, so now we do timeout in her room.
    I think it depends on what they have done to warrant a smack, and if talking to the first isnt working – where do you go from there…. I am not against smacking – bit it doesnt really work for us


  • If you speak to your child and teach them right from wrong early on then it shouldn’t be necessary.
    I know children and animals are not the same but in training an animal you base it on respect – the animal wants to please and get praised. Positive reinforcement is all it should take. If course children will test you and play up but smacking only instills fear / upset etc – life should be a positive experience


  • I don’t think it is effective but have done it myself – then felt incredibly guilty.


  • Personally I do not believe in it. We have enough violence in society with out introducing it into our homes. Would you let your husband smack you for doing something wrong? Of course not, that’s domestic violence!
    There are many other ways to discipline children I just do not think smacking should even be considered.
    I was smacked as a child & it has left me with mixed feelings towards my father as a result. Don’t do it to your children, they will not forget & they will not accept it was a form of punishment when they are older.


  • I am all for a tap on the hand or nappy, but only as a last resort.


  • I don’t like it. I wasn’t smacked, my brothers were walloped! My kids got the occasional slap, but I never felt good after


  • Try not to! It is good reading the comments and interest to this!


  • Never smack when angry. A controlled smack on the hand, or butt is fine. But it must be done in a way the child understands why.


  • I am absolutely against smacking. Read this article by Alice Miller. I agree completely with what she says.
    http://www.alice-miller.com/flyers_en.php?page=2


Post you answer
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

What is your answer to that question?
Would you like to include a photo?
No picture uploaded yet.
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.
Your MoM account


Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your answer and join MoM:

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join