24 Answers

I’m not having any luck with my banana muffins! After following the recipe it ended up a flop!

Posted by , 17th March 2015

Want more real mum questions sent to you?

You'll need to check this email to complete your signup.


Ask your question
  • Are you using self raising flour, not plain? And I think over-mixing the dough can also have a bad effect.

  • I had the same issue with a chocolate muffin recipe. I was told it was either too much sugar or I should have used caster sugar instead of the usual sugar. Try another recipe, I’m sure you’ll find one that works

  • Did you open the oven during the middle of cooking? I’ve had a lovely cake baking before and opened the oven to check it, to have it sag down with sadness.

  • I would double check all the ingredients. You might have to compare your recipe to others to see if there’s something missing.

  • If you’re using bi-carb or baking powder, check the use by date. If they’re old they’re not that efficient. Get some fresh ingredients.

  • Are you maybe over mixing? This will produce flat tough muffins. Are you using the right flour?

  • Use self raising flour and baking soda.

  • Try adding baking soda
    And I use paper fouls so don’t need to Greece the tins
    Also may not be cooked long enough
    Has your door to the oven been slammed close
    Or is your oven door closing properly when cooking?
    I have the opposite problem mine blow up like a balloon
    I use. Fresh flour too when making cakes and muffins
    Once open flour make sure you store it in air tight container for no longer then1 month

  • It could be a few things:
    * over mixing – muffins are best if the wet ingredients are mixed enough to bring them together, but not much more.
    * timing – it’s best to add the wet ingredients to the dry at the very last stage of preparing. Make sure the oven is hot because you don’t want the mixture sitting once combined.
    * Not enough baking powder – If you’re using plain flour, add two teaspoons of baking powder per cup of flour.
    I hope this helps :-)

  • yeah don’t be discouraged. you need to bake, bake, bake to learn what to do.

  • I know sometimes it may seem a little expensive, but try not to use homebrand flours. I find White Wings to be one of the best brands for cake baking. For pasta and noodles I use an Italian brand, by the name of Miloni Pizzuti. Have fun and good luck! :)

  • I find mixing sr flour & warm milk seems to fluff it up more ,activates flour .

  • It sounds to me like your muffin mix was a little too moist.! You may have followed the recipe exactly but sometimes the flour you use may not be as absorbent as it should so you have to add a little more to slightly thicken the mix . Best of luck next time. kindest regards, Robyn.

  • another tip is when you pull the tray out of the oven, tap the bottom of the tray on the edge of the oven, it helps adjust the baked goods to the cooler room temp and this will help to stop the muffins caving in on themselves

  • sounds if it is too wet so add some baking powder and use SR flour.

Post you answer
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Add a photo
Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your answer and join MoM:

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating