Thank you for some suggestions. I ended up finding a dress, necklace and small over the shoulder handbag for her birthday and playdoh for Christmas. She loved both.

I think any art & craft material and anything for pretend play is always good

you cant go wrong with books!

We love it when our kids get gifted arts and crafts or books. Personally we have enough toys and they tend to get bored with them. Cheap colouring in books and some pencils or crayons are great. Places like kmart also do some great arts and craft kits and buckets. We got them for rainy days and the kids love creating stuff.

My daughter and niece are around the same age and they love anything girly, hair elastics, makeup, stuffed toys, a girly handbag, there’s lots of cute clothes out atm too. Anything cute or sparkly I find is liked alot! I hope this helps and good luck!

Books
Arts and crafts
Experience such as a day at the zoo
A voucher she can use during a day out shopping with you and a special lunch