Hello!

44 Comments

Some of the best childhood memories are made at sleepovers – staying up until all hours giggling and eating lollies, playing truth or dare, or watching movie after movie.

But a child psychiatrist has revealed that he would never allow his children to attend sleepovers, because of the lifelong ‘trauma’ they can cause.

Dr Mitnaul, a child and adolescent psychiatrist, and father of six, shared five things he would never allow his children to do, and the video caused a stir:

“Number one: let my kids have their own smartphone. Not today, not in my house,” Dr Mitnaul explained.

“Number two: put a television in my child’s room. Number three: talk negatively about my spouse in front of my kids. Number four: do everything for my child so that they don’t develop habits like discipline and chores. And number five: I would never, ever, ever, ever do a sleepover.”

The video prompted lots of parents to question why he wouldn’t allow his children to attend sleepovers, so Dr Mitnaul replied with a detailed response.

@doctormitnaul Part 2 – Why I don’t allow sleepovers ???? #5things #psychiatrist #childpsychiatrist #psychiatristsoftiktok #nosleepovers #thingsiwontdo #explained #parttwo ♬ Monkeys Spinning Monkeys – Kevin MacLeod & Kevin The Monkey

He prefaced his explanation by identifying what he means by ‘sleepovers’ – that is when kids sleepover at their friends’ place – as opposed to with grandparents or aunts and their cousins.

In the video, which has been viewed more than two million times, he goes on to explain exactly why childhood sleepovers aren’t allowed in his house.

“Often the stories that come into us about trauma, about exposures, about inappropriate things in the lives of things are often at the corners of experiences of our kids. And by corners I mean those places where there’s let adult supervision, they’re a group of kids together maybe doing more impulsive things or things that they wouldn’t otherwise do under the careful watch and gaze of a loving adult.

“And so sleepovers often provide the right opportunity for kids to get into things that are way over their heads. Whether they intend to or not.

“And so if my intention is for my child to have wonderful and close relationships with their peers and for me to have a close relationship with my child I’m going to make sure that they do that in a situation and time that is most likely to be profitable for them and less likely to leave them scarred with trauma from which they might need to heal from for the rest of their lives.”

Sleepover

However, his response was also met with plenty of resistance, including from therapists, who commented that the benefits of sleepovers outweigh the risks.

But there were also lots of parents and experts who supported Dr Mitnaul’s stance.

“Sleepovers are either fun experiences or tragic ones. I won’t take that risk with my kids because if something bad happens, you can never undo it,” commented JGlo.

What are your thoughts? Do you allow your children to attend sleepovers? Let us know in the comments below. 

We may get commissions for purchases made using links in this post. Learn more.
  • My kids are to young but I am not sure if I will be happy to let them go.

    Reply

  • I never let my kids have sleepovers or even let there friends sleepover either

    Reply

  • The only time my boys went on sleepovers was with people that I knew and trusted would look out for them.

    Reply

  • I don’t think I’ll let my kids have sleepovers.
    I went to them a lot as a child and it was fine, although once when I was about 11 I had a sleepover at a friend’s house and we watched Scream and it scarred me for life. I still have a major phobia of anyone in any type of mask and it took me years to be ok around glass at nighttime ????‍♀️

    Reply

  • I didn’t let my daughter do sleepovers with friends mainly because we did not know the hosts well enough. She did have sleepovers with her grandparents.

    Reply

  • My kids have gone for sleeperovers but are older now but they also knew that if at any stage they wanted to come home, all they had to do was call and I would come get them ANYTIME.

    Reply

  • I was initially very reluctant to do any sleepovers. Till my sister and her family came over from Africa and spent 4 weeks with us. My niece was the same age as the daughter of my neighbour and they created a lovely friendship. The daughter of my neighbour (who was and is still my friend) really wanted to sleepover and join us in this special occasion. I gave in and this totally caused a shift in my thinking.

    Reply

  • A strict age limit has always been must for us.


    • Relationships and trust need to be firmly established.

    Reply

  • We live in the country so frequently have city friends come to stay for a sleepover. The older kids love the freedom and independence they get whilst being here.

    Reply

  • I used to occasionally have sleepovers with friends of my parents and their daughter who was a year older than I. Fortunately I am still here today, but I remember her trying to drown me, and always pinching and hurting me, because she didn’t want me there. The parents never discussed it with either of us, if they had, they might not have thought it was such a great thing to do. So I definitely agree with this doctor wholeheartedly.


    • How awful, that must have been a traumatic experience !



      • Sorry this happened. Just reinforces why sleepovers are not always good for kids.

    Reply

  • I have a friend who doesn’t let her kids sleep over at friends and I was thinking of doing the same. Still let them hang out but pick them up at bedtime

    Reply

  • I stick to very close family only. Strictly no friends.

    Reply

  • I wasn’t allowed to go to sleepovers unless my parents knew the other family really well and now as a parent I would also hesitate to let my son attend a sleepover unless I knew the family well. Kids can get up to some crazy things sometimes and it can be hard to police.

    Reply

  • This is very interesting.. I agree some sleepovers can go horribly wrong, but when I think to my childhood I have so many good memories from sleepovers.. very torn here!

    Reply

  • I think this definitely depends on the situation ie age of kids/number of kids, reason for sleepover and most importantly how well I know the parents where the sleepover is taking place.

    Reply

Post a comment
Add a photo
Your MoM account


Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like

Loading…

Looks like this may be blocked by your browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join