Having a child is a decision made by both parents; one could argue the wife is breaking the wedding vows by not respecting her husbands view.
The motivation she want this child -to help with the grieving process- is not good.
Frankly I think this wife is rather manipulative

Having a baby isn’t going to make the grief of losing her parents go away. The issue of grief and wanting another child are both very significant but very seperate issues. Both may require counselling.

One person cant get angry at the other for not wanting another child! It’s a joint decision that needs to be made by you both after discussion. I think maybe you both need to go and speak to someone

It’s not being selfish to not want more children. I didn’t think you could get a reversal and it was a joint decision to have it done anyway. If you’re not sure, instead of arguing find out first if it is possible for it to be done. You may find that the argument is moot. It’s not a good way to have a child to help you grieve over the loss of a parent.

It’s a joint decision, both people should agree without coercion. It’s not selfish to not want any more kids.

This is not the answer to help someone grieve. I am with the husband on this one, babies should be bought into this world for a positive reason not because of grief

A few things… grieving is not the right reason to want another child. Grief is a huge process that needs to be worked through and big life decisions shouldn’t be made at this time. And secondly, communication is key. You’re not being selfish, you had a plan. Plans definitely can change, but if this is nearing divorce, clearly there may be other issues at play. You need to communicate and come to a decision that you can both live with. I think she needs help with her grief.

I was thinking about what the article says that the wife wants another baby to help her with the grieving process of her parent that passed: not the right motivation to have a child in my opinion

i think its selfish as in this world raising the children. 6th child not really a goods thing

I honestly think the wife should try counselling first. They obviously both decided 5 children were enough for the husband to get a vasectomy and i really dont think grief is a good reason to have another child.

I’m not seeing selfish at all. They already have 5 children. He’s had a vasectomy. There’s lots to consider beyond helping her through the grieving process. If anything, she’s being selfish and using emotional blackmail to get what she wants.

Oh, and if you need emotional support buy a puppy!

• • 
  • • Ellen replied
    • 17 Nov 2023 , 8:59 am

  ---

  

  Yes, I agree. A pet can be a good alternative

The father is not being selfish at all! A child is a lifetime commitment- not a counsellor! It’s selfish wanting to have one to help you in your grief, they are rewarding, but also taxing and it’s just going to become a huge strain. Secondly, the poor guy has already had a vasectomy- asking him to get it reversed when they already have 5 kids is a huge ask and not guaranteed to work. She’s also getting older and I’d be concerned about the strain on her body too. The whole thing is just silly.

I think the desire for another child needs to come from both side. The wife saying that he’s inconsiderate of her and that he broke their wedding vows by not being there for her in her time of need, is in my opinion kind of an emotional blackmail.
I think some psychological help for the wife to help her in her grieving process would be appropriate

She also needs to be considerate of her husband and children. It’s a two way street.

A baby shouldn’t be used or made to help heal a grieving period. It’s best she sees a professional for her grieving and possible as a couple too.

NTA. Babies aren’t emotional support animals. While grief is personal and takes many forms, especially over parents (I’m unfortunately not a stranger to this), its gauche to want another child as a distraction from healing the root cause of the issue. Therapy is the first step here, otherwise the wife might end up projecting some heavy emotions and expectations onto a child.

I think your wife needs counselling desperately. She should also realise that your going through reversal surgery doesn’t necessarily mean it will work, depending on how long ago you had the vasectomy. And she could be putting you through a great deal of discomfort for nothing. You really both need to have a mediator to fix up your ailing marriage – her grief over losing her parents won’t be lessened by having another child.

No you are not the a***ole. You did the right thing by getting a vasectomy as you both didn’t want anymore kids, Grieving her parents and having a baby is not the way to go. Her parents will still be deceased. I think your wife needs to see someone about her grief as she obviously isn’t dealing with it.

you both need to agree i think its so important