Hello!

January 22, 2021

60 Comment

One mum confesses she regrets her decision to hold her child back from school for another year.

Sharing with MoM she sadly wrote: “Oh mums, I feel awful. It was such a difficult decision to make but I really did feel that I did the right thing by giving my daughter another year in pre-school.

“But when I dropped off my son and seen the ‘big school’ kids, I have the biggest doubt that I made a BIG mistake.

“She should be there too, in her school uniform learning all sorts of things. Instead, it feels like she’s wasting her time playing around. I know people say that you won’t ever regret ‘keeping them back’ but I do.”

MoM’s share their advice

Our kind mums have shared their wise words of wisdom with some even saying it is NEVER too late to enrol if you think that is what is best for your child.

Other mums said:

Sarah kindly advised: “Play is the most important part of learning for young children. Don’t think she’s wasting time. She is getting so many skills out of it that will prepare her for the social/emotional aspects of school, as well as developing important fine & gross motor skills imperative to success in academics.”

Tina agreed: “Play is an important part of learning and it’s never wasted. She won’t miss out on anything, she will still learn. Don’t beat yourself up, it isn’t permanent and it won’t impact her negatively in anyway. You did the right thing.”

They May Not Be Ready

Karan added: “It’s crueler to put them in before they’re ready and then they see all their little friends move up while they stay in kindy. You know your own child and if you had doubts about her ability to cope then you did the right thing keeping her back a year.”

Amanda said: “If you had sent her this year, you might of still be doubting that you did the right thing. Next year, she will have gained more socially, and you will never doubt it again, as it is not going to be a bad thing at all.”

Susan said: “No harm done. It all sorts itself out in the wash. Chances are she will be more on top of things when she does start school and be able to take more of a lead in class which is great for confidence. Also if you think she is ready there are always the weekends and after school for ‘learning’ with you! Imagine what you can do to help broaden her experience (eg music, reading, drawing, art, dance, sport etc.) without all the distracting routine of school that ended up taking up WAY more time that we would have liked in the early years.”

What the experts say

Research is constantly being done on whether it benefits a child to delay starting school or if it actually harms them. The research is quite conflicting because many researchers find that it benefits your child a great deal to start school later and others feel that there is either no impact or it benefits them.

Positives to a delayed start:

  • They are more mature.
  • They are the oldest in the classroom.
  • They perform better academically.
  • They have more confidence.

Negatives to a delayed start:

  • It can be hard if all your child’s friends start school and he or she is left behind.
  • They might get irritated with their younger peers in the class.
  • The advantage the child had at the beginning of their school careers will eventually fade when the other kids start catching up.

It can be overwhelming for parents, however, you know your child best. You know what your child is capable of. You have seen your child at their best and at their worst. It is important to trust yourself and your instinct as a parent.

When In Doubt…Give Them An Extra Year Of Play

Dr. Nadia Louw, Educational Psychologist says that when you are in doubt, keep them back.

She says that as parents you might feel like you are giving your child an academic edge, but it can cause untold damage if they are not ready for formal education. “It is like forcing a little fledgling from the nest before its wings are fully developed.”

“The impact on the child’s academic self-concept and ability to learn can be great. So parents have to think carefully when making this decision.” She also says every child is different and it really depends on them.

What did you do? Did you send your kids to school “on the early side” or gave them another year of play? Tell us in the comments below.

  • I’m grateful that I don’t have the decision to make too.

    Reply

  • Once the decision is made it’s best to just go with it and not have regrets.

    Reply

  • Years ago i made my son repeat year 6 and it’s the best decision I made, back then I was also worried and scared if I was doing the wrong thing but my son is alot happier and academically alot better too
    At the moment he is year 11 and still till today he says “Thankyou mum I’m glad you made me repeat.”

    Reply

  • I feel comforted in a strange way that my son doesn’t start school until he is 5 (his birthday is in the 2nd half of the year) so I didn’t have to make that decision. I think the extra year in soft school is a better transition for him

    Reply

  • We never had concerns, so sent our kids “on time” – but I can appreciate how hard this decision is for many.

    Reply

  • My brother was kept back in grade 1 and home schooled in yr 9. He said it was the best thing that happened as he was able to be confident in his knowledge before moving on.

    Reply

  • When I went to school it was based on your birth month and so being born in August I was held back an extra year. I wanted to go but once there was truly not ready for school at all, luckily my older sister was there as every bell that was rung I thought was the home bell and I was off and running. Funny thing was we had to catch a bus to and from school. But I survived, we all do and they’re some of the best years of our lives.

    Reply

  • I had a child with high functioning Aspergers and, because of a stint in Victoria, ended up being one of the younger students in his class. Whilst academically he was flying and teachers would not allow him to go down a class level, I saw a very big difference in what was being expected of him (in grade 6) compared with his younger sister (grade 4) who was less than a year younger than him. He was miserable and I dreaded the thought of him having to start High School the next year. He was in a composite class so he just stayed in the 5/6 again instead of going to high school. It was the best thing I ever did. He started to enjoy school and, when he got to high school, wasn’t missing out on the stages all the others were going through, including his friends – eg, being old enough to learn to drive and turning 18. Academically, he didn’t miss out as he was simply put on a program for gifted students and, now he is in Uni, age doesn’t even matter. I think it is important to remember that being intelligent and learning alone will not make a child happy and provide a well-balanced life. Let them be a child for as long as they can and, if they need intellectual stimulation, give them educational activity books or buy educational software/fun learning games.

    Reply

  • i have a son born in January and i have received letters from the government advising me that my child will be on the younger side of the class as many people hold their children back. I have decided to send him as he is such a bright spark and really wants to go. If i need to hold him back at another year level then i can do it then

    Reply

  • I sent my daughter to school when her age dictated but this was the worst decision EVER. She struggled her whole 12 years of schooling as she was one of the youngest in her class. When we moved to Tasmania from Melbourne I asked that she be held back because I realized my mistake but they refused. They said even if I had held her back, they would have put her into the age appropriate class – even though she wasn’t coping – STUPID SYSTEM!!

    Reply

  • No use to regret a decision you can’t turn around. We make a decision with the best of our intentions and every child is different and it’s good to look at that.

    Reply

  • I feel like my little miss is academically ready but socially I’m worried for her

    Reply

  • You made the decision that you thought was best. Every child is different and develops at their own rate. Dont beat yourself up about it, I’m sure she will be fine. She has a mum who obviously loves her and worries about her. That to me is a sign of a great mum.

    Reply

  • I have a baby born on June 30th, which means that she can technically start school that year and be the youngest in the class or we can keep her home a year and have her be the eldest in the class. We are as yet undecided as she is a baby, but will see how she is socially and academically, before deciding. The pros and cons can’t be done by researchers, it is different for each child.

    Reply

  • Depends on the child! If I had a march or Aprils baby I’d definitely consider it, or if I felt they lacked the maturity in general..

    Reply

  • Every child is different and you need to do what is best for your child.

    Reply

  • I totally agree that each child is different, and each goes at their own pace…. BUT!!!! It was a HUGE MISTAKE for me. My sister went early, and my mum thought she was so little, so I went late. My sister did fantastically at school,. Her and the other youngest girl in the school got the highest scores at vce than the r rest of the school. Me on the other hand: was bored ALL the way through school, nothing challenged me, I had to wait 3 years instead of 2 to join my sister in Melbourne after high school….. I was capable and could get A’s without a second thought, but instead was bored out of my brain, I acted out and nearly failed instead. I’ve had anger issues with my parents and the schools I attended ever since and I’m in my forties. I have my own children now, and my youngest boy turns 3 in 2 weeks- he IS going to preprep this year. He’s more than ready, and I’ve read the research…. Even if he’s not quite ready, or slower than some of the girls (because boys tend to mature later), it is written that they catch up by the age of about 7…. and then they’re fine!


    • Sorry to hear you had this experience mom367316 !

    Reply

  • Each kid is different.but i like reading all the support responses

    Reply

  • Each child is different. Do what you think is the right thing instinctively.

    Reply

  • I sent mine to school at their appropriate ages and I’m glad we did. My eldest two were older in their grade and the youngest one was younger. She did struggle with some things at the start but by half way through the year she pick up and was the same as her peers. I have a younger son starting prep this year and he’s so eager to start.

    Reply

Post a comment

To post a review/comment please join us or login so we can allocate your points.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join