Hello!

37 Comment

Most of us grew up with rules around dinner – whether it was to at least try everything or to make sure you finishing everything on your plate.

But is putting food-related expectations on our kids outdated? And does it foster an unhealthy relationship with food?

A 29-year-old mums says she’s had a falling out with her mother-in-law, after she tried to force her four-year-old daughter to eat vegetables that she doesn’t like. The mum of two, who also has a two-year-old son and is pregnant says the family was having dinner at her husband’s parents’ house over the weekend, when the argument unfolded.

“They always do DIY style dinners where we serve ourselves,” the mum explained. “My daughter does not like broccoli or Brussels sprouts and so when I helped her with her plate, we left those off and included all the other veggies on the plate because she likes those.

“MIL saw that we had not included two of the veggies and went and added a small amount of each to her plate. She then told my daughter to try at least everything on her plate. My daughter said she doesn’t like them (this is when my husband and I heard what his mum was doing because we had already started digging in and helping our two-year-old). We told MIL to stop and she doesn’t need to eat those.

“MIL argued that they were on her plate and every kid needs the rule that you need to at least try a bite of everything. I told her it was not our rule and I did not put those things on my daughter’s plate. She said she did because she should eat them. My husband told her to leave it alone. She told my daughter yet again to eat the broccoli and sprouts and I told her she cannot force my child to eat something she doesn’t want.

“MIL yelled and told me I am going to raise a picky eater with a bad attitude toward food if I didn’t stop catering to her like that. My husband became enraged and told his mum she was out of line, cruel and she owed us an apology. MIL and him argued it out until my husband and I left early.”

Untitled design - 2023-04-19T144641.882

The woman says her own past with eating disorders has helped her formulate how she’s raising her own children.

“I was diagnosed with OCD and anorexia when I was 13. I had a very unhealthy relationship with food my whole childhood. Part of that, it is believed, was due to how strict my parents were about food. They did not believe you could dislike a piece of food and would always insist I eat everything and eat it all up.

“They would berate me, yell at me and intimidate me into eating the stuff I did not like. It created some bad compulsions that led to me starving myself through a large portion of my childhood. I was removed from my parents thanks to my grandparents stepping in when at the age of 13 I passed out in school and was rushed to the hospital. I was malnourished, weak as a preemie kitten and I did almost lose my life because of it.

“It took several years for any kind of healthy attitude to food to begin and I am very much still a work in progress. So MIL saying what she did really upset my husband because MIL is aware of what I went through and that I of all people do know what an unhealthy attitude to food is like.

“Despite all this, my telling MIL she couldn’t force my daughter to eat something started off a big chain reaction and I wonder if I’m the a**hole for saying it to her like that and whether I could have made things less explosive.”

What do you think of this situation? Let us know in the comments below. 

  • As parents we provide the food and it is up to our child to decide what they want and the amount they feel like eating.
    Force feeding doesn’t help anyone, only causes more stress and anxiety around mealtimes

    Reply

  • I’m in the same boat as the OP. I have eating disorders related to how food was treated, presented and forced upon me even when I was allergic to it.
    OP and her husband should stick to what they believe to raise their children

    Reply

  • Grand parents should accept and respect the rules and strategies implemented by the parents full stop.

    Reply

  • Food should just be food and not forced to try any of it. MIL needs to respect her son and daughter in laws parenting choices

    Reply

  • It’s really important that the MIL respect her parenting choices, especially when she knows her background relationship with food. This sounds like it would have been quite triggering. Clear communication between the adults here would help a lot.

    Reply

  • We always encourage trying but dont force feed our children. Our children also know once dinner is served nothing else will be prepared for those that dislike dinner. My kids have been good eaters and try almost anything but if they dislike they dont eat it. I do have friends who struggle with their kids and it can be very difficult when a child just refuses everything.

    Reply

  • Feeding kids is a real can of worms and everyone brings their own experience and baggage to the situation. Yelling and berating a child to do anything is never a great idea.

    Reply

  • We always just ask our kids to try, and they are more than ok to spit out if they choose, and this works for us. She had no right to dictate to YOUR child. Its your way of parenting.

    Reply

  • It’s definitely hard at you want your kids to eat things like veggies.
    My little boy at the moment is SUPER picky and doesn’t really eat much but chips, nuggets and bread and it’s quite frustrating as I know he’s not getting all the nutrients he needs and it’s worrying me that he will get quite sick from this type of attitude.

    Reply

  • We always give our daughter what we eat, but with zero expectations. There’s always one food we know she will ear and everything else is a “in case she wants to try it” but never force her as that’s a surefire way to cause issues with food.

    Reply

  • Everyone has a different parenting style and can do what works for them. I have a very fussy eater and find it hard. I have tried everything and now just let it be and hope that she will in time be willing to try things again.

    Reply

  • You ARE going to raise a child without resilience. You are putting your trauma onto your parenting.
    But, it is your child – so everyone must obey your rules if they want to interact with them.

    Reply

  • NTA.
    Your child, your choice.
    When I started parenting, I had the eat everything on your plate mentality.
    Little did I know my daughter had sensory issues and this was the reason for a lot of food avoidance.
    She is now more willing to try things at her pace if I ask would you like to, instead of you have to as she doesn’t feel like she is disappointed or failing. If she tries it, great. If not, that’s cool too.

    Reply

Post a comment

To post a review/comment please join us or login so we can allocate your points.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join