Hello!

157 Comment

Weighing up what’s best for your baby, your budget and your planet

Every mother has her own individual point of view on the age-old debate of diapers. Today’s nappy choices can seem endless, unlike our ancestral mothers whom were forced to use accessible materials from Mother Nature to protect their baby’s bottom.

The Inuits placed moss under sealskin as an early form of diapers, while, both Native American and Inca mothers packed grass under a rabbit skin diaper cover. Cloth diapers were only introduced in the late 1800s. Even then, it wasn’t until the mid 1900s that cloth diapers had met its match with the invention of disposable diapers.

It’s safe to say that modern-day mummies have many more options than our grandmothers – from disposable, biodegradable disposable, prefold cloth nappies, to all in one reusables, just to name a few. Ultimately, your decision will come down to cost, environmental impact and, more importantly, your personal preference.

So here’s the scoop on poop… disposable vs washable nappies!

Washable diapers

Most of our mothers, our mother’s mothers, and even all the mother’s before them have all done it. The process of mum’s struggling for hours in the laundry soaking sheets and terry towelling, rinsing, washing, drying and folding, is no more. But washable diapers have even evolved quite far since the days of developing a talent of folding flat squares and clasping oversized diaper pins with one hand (avoiding stabbing your little one in the tummy!).

There are over 200 brands of washable diapers on the market, with cost and value varying as well. It is important to invest in good quality reusable nappies, taking into consideration that you will be washing them every day for almost three years. The initial start-up cost of 20 reusable nappies, boosters and liners is estimated to be around $500. This cost does not factor in laundering costs of water, electricity and washing powder.

Pea Pods are a popular brand, at under $20 a pair they are a snug fit, breathable, and use ultra absorbent bamboo lining. When disposable nappies can cost over $1 per nappy and you’re using 5-6 a day, think of the savings not only to your hip pocket but for the environment too.

Related: School lunches from $2 a day

Extra time and planning

Compared to the nappies of convenience, washable diapers take up more time for laundering and drying the nappies. Holidays and weekends can also contribute to issues such as finding facilities to soak and wash soiled diapers. Even winter can cause a problem as it becomes harder to air-dry washed cloths. Simply put, washable diapers require just a small extra level of planning.

Nappy service companies can assist with these domestic duties. Lavenderia NappyCare wash, dry, and fold reusable cloth nappies, facilities the process for busy mums as they can wash and home deliver up to 60 nappies for $25 per week. Overall, this luxury would cost almost the same amount as the overall cost of disposable nappies.

Water borne waste

With daily washing, reusable diapers require a large amount of water for soaking, washing and rinsing. Washable diapers produce four times more water borne waste than disposables. They also require the use of detergents to sanitise the soiled diapers that end up polluting the water system, unless you’re using earth care or bio degradable laundry products – bicarb and vinegar usually does the trick!

The environmental impact of reusable diapers can be reduced depending on laundering usage, such as choosing air-dry over tumble-dry.

Related: 50 Ways to reduce your power bills

Disposable diapers

Due to accessibility and cost, disposable nappies only became popular in the last couple of decades. The design has evolved drastically, with mothers at the forefront lines of the development.

Assuming your baby will need up to two and a half years worth of basic disposable diapers until he or she is potty-trained, Baby Soft Landings calculated the total cost would be at least $3339. This value also includes the cost of one packet of disposable wipes a week. As a new mother, it may take a bit of experimenting with brands and types to find the right fit for your baby.

Think of the savings you could make if you were putting your diaper costs into a high rate savings account over the course of three years? 

Nappies of convenience

Disposable diapers are often labelled the nappies of convenience as they can be bought and binned anywhere. Being portable and disposable it’s easy to become dependent upon them for their convince and time saving advantages.

Disposed in a landfill

Traditional disposable diapers produce four times more solid waste than cloth nappies. Disposable diapers are produced with synthetics, such as bleach, plastics, and adhesives. Raw materials like wood pulp are also used to fill the nappy.

Disposable nappies are believed to take roughly 500 years to break down. According to a study conducted by the Environment Agency on the lifecycle of disposable nappies, every child wearing nappies accounts for 1-2 tonnes of waste to landfill over their lifetime!

Related: How much can you save with solar panels?

Biodegradable Nappies

Recently, biodegradable nappies have become more accessible to mothers who would like to be more conscious of the environment. Actress Jessica Alba recently founded The Honest Company to promote and sell natural and eco-friendly baby products. Created with the idea of only using organic materials and products on your baby’s skin cleansing the materials that touch a baby’s skin, The Honest Co. features baby-care to household-cleaner products.

Along with reading all the informative parenting books, it is important to research your extensive diaper options. You might decide on washable nappies for days spent at home and disposables for when you go out and about.

A lot of the time it will come down to trial and error; whether it be washable, disposable, biodegradable, you will find the right nappy or combination that works best for your baby and your budget, as well as the planet.

Written by Melissa Cortes, Yahoo!7 Moneyhound – Fetching you a better deal. Moneyhound.com.au is a price comparison site that can help you save money across all your monthly bills. Try it now, it’s free.
Looking for more ways to save?
  • I lived the history component of this article. Thank you. The use of either depends on what else is going on in your life.

    Reply

  • My sister used cloth and I commend her. At around 6months her little girl got a bad nappy rash, the Dr advised her to use disposal and she hasn’t looked back.

    Reply

  • I have no idea how people find time to use cloth.

    Reply

  • I wasn’t time poor so used cloth. They really do take time to wash, etc., but the plus side is how cheap they were. Just comes down to personal preference.


    • this is how I feel, with time being precious, those disposable ones are so convenient!

    Reply

  • Washable nappies seem much better for the environment and don’t 500 years to decompose.
    The problem I had was I was so busy as a new mum and very stressed I found disposable nappies easier. And since I didn’t have a dryer in winter it would have been impossible to dry. Lots to consider.

    Reply

  • I think use what suits you and your lifestyle.


    • I agree, you have to do what works for you. I do think there are a lot of people that don’t give cloth a chance though, they just don’t want to have to wash nappies so they stay away from them. I’ve used terry toweling squares and MCN’s and found MCN’s soooo easy to wash, so much easier than scrubbing the terry toweling ones.

    Reply

  • I’ve mainly used disposable but have a few pairs of MCNs for my eldest son, and will probably do the same for my newest son. They are particularly good in summer to avoid the dreaded nappy rash in the heat! Would have liked to have used them more, but don’t quite live in the right climate for winter babies who poo and wee a LOT!! 😉

    This is my first little boy rocking his dinosaur print MCN 😀

    Reply

  • I would have liked to have used washable nappies but every one around me kept telling me why would you when we have the convenience of disposable. It’s really personal preference in the end.

    Reply

  • I used a bit of both. Luckily my aunt bought me a load of cloth nappies when my first son was born so that saved us money and even luckier my dad had just retired and there was nothing he liked better than coming around to see his grandson and then he would spend time with me also washing the same cloth nappies for me. (Love my dad). But once I went back to college I used disposables when he was in the creche. It all depends on the time you have, money, how many children you have and how much you care about the environment.

    Reply

  • I have done half/half for my Son Im Hoping with my New Baby I can stick to just Cloth


    • Good luck with it, once you get in the routine you’ll be fine 🙂

    Reply

  • I wanted to use cloth nappies but when it came to my twins being born it was too much of a hassle my clothes line was just nappies and no room for normal clothes and to much time so I got sucked in and changed to disposables but if I had one, I will do the cloth just too hard with 2 babies.

    Reply

  • I prefer disposable nappies, just because I struggle to keep on top of washing as it is!!! My hubbys a mechanic so that is endless scrubbing & soaking as it is. Each & everyone to their own but 🙂

    Reply

  • I used cloth nappies with my eldest. I really wish I hadnt. My eldest was a bit of a nightmare baby and cried an extreme amount and she never slept so it was always my only chore that i got done daily…if i was lucky…to wash and hang out the nappies. I could have taken some of the pressure off me if I had use disposable.
    I used them for my next two.

    Reply

  • I used cloth for my first two bubs but the convenience of disposable won over the last two,

    Reply

  • i tried to do cloth, but it just didnt work for me. disposables are so easy, especially when your out and about.

    Reply

  • I use both, save money but also have the convenience

    Reply

  • I started using cloth wanted to only use cloth but as the months turned into wet winter, I found I was surrounded by a lounge full of never ending drying nappies. Not much fun with an open fire and no room. I finally changed to disposables after going back to work. Didn’t like using them but really saved my sanity.

    Reply

  • Cloth nappies DO NOT NEED SOAKING. They are dry pailed. Also, even with washing cloth nappies for a number of years (over multiple children) they still use less water than to produce disposable nappies. I wish it listed the amount of water needed to product a sposie here. Also – I’m not sure how disposables are more hygienic. You are still required to put the poo in the toilet (as it is against council garbage service to put poo in bin) and you wear cloth knickers yourself. I know I’d rather have a natural fabric on my bubs, I’m trying to reduce the amount of chemicals in our life and the chemicals in disposable nappies are pretty scary. YES – there is a bit of time involved. But It is something I am prepared to do and if organised enough it is not too bad. I compare it to take away dinners. Of course it is ‘easier’ to get takeaway but there is nothing like a home-cooked meal. I am not against disposable nappies as such, but I do think the facts about cloth nappies are VERY often misrepresented.

    Reply

  • While I’d love to say I want to cloth diaper my kids, it’s really not an option for me. I have enough laundry as it is with three men in my house and laundry is one of my most hated chores… But good on the mum’s who can and do cloth diaper!

    Reply

  • I’ve used them all! On my first child I mostly used terry towelling squares but put her in disposables if we were going somewhere or for sleeping because I got sick of washing the sheets because she’d wet through the nappy. My second child I mostly had in MCN’s but occasionally used disposables. Modern Cloth Nappies are fantastic, they’re so much easier to wash than most people think, and I like to do my bit for the environment.

    Reply

Post a comment

To post a review/comment please join us or login so we can allocate your points.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join