Hello!

35 Comment

A ‘fed-up’ mum says she’s sick of parents ‘gently’ disciplining their children after her toddler was repeatedly hit by an older child.

The woman says she took her 18-month-old to a soft-play centre, and was shocked when a four-year-old boy began hitting the little girl.

“(He) was whacking my 18-month-old, pushing her down, kicked her in the face,” the woman explained on Mumsnet. “Obviously I kept intervening and actually told him off myself but his parent was nowhere to be seen.

“Once I’d told him off he moved onto a different toddler whose mum approached me and asked if I knew who his parent was. said parent eventually came over and said, ‘Aw is he being rough?’

“I said, ‘Yes he’s being very aggressive to multiple toddlers, has hit/kicked/pushed and keeps following them around even after other parents are intervening’. And her response was ‘Ohh (child’s name) you need to be more gentle!’ in a soft voice then walked off and he continued.”

The exchange left the mum fuming, saying there are certain times that call for harsher discipline.

“Sorry but WTF. If your child is as feral as that, surely you say, ‘Right we’re leaving’ and actually tell them off instead of that response? Seems to be a common occurrence too, always seems to be the most aggressive kids who are being gentle parented.”

It prompted other mums to comment that what this mum witnessed wasn’t ‘gentle parenting’.

“That’s called lack of parenting, not gentle parenting,” wrote one mum.

Another responded: “This is not gentle parenting. If you’re following gentle parenting techniques then you ensure that inappropriate behaviour is met with relevant consequences – in this case removing the child who’s hurting others from the situation and explaining why they can’t play if they’re going to hurt others. What you experienced was simply indulgent parenting – very frustrating but completely different.”

What do you think? Let us know in the comments below.

  • I think this is more a matter of unresponsive parenting.
    “Unresponsive parenting,” often called “uninvolved parenting” or “neglectful parenting,” is a parenting style where parents show a lack of responsiveness to their child’s needs, emotions, and desires, essentially not actively engaging with their child beyond providing basic necessities like food and shelter; this can include emotional distance, minimal supervision, and little to no support or guidance

    Reply

  • I agree is not gentle parrenting as with gentle parenting still healthy boundaries are ste.
    However I don’t think this is dismissive parenting.
    Dismissive parenting is a style where a parent consistently ignores or minimizes their child’s emotions, often treating their feelings as unimportant, invalid, or something to simply “get over,” effectively dismissing their child’s emotional needs and creating a disconnect in the parent-child relationship; this can manifest through ignoring, downplaying, or distracting the child when they express negative emotions.
    I think this is more a matter of unresponsive parenting.

    Reply

  • It’s been said many times, that is not gentle parenting, it is dismissive parenting. Gentle parenting still involves setting boundaries and having consequences. It doesn’t mean you excuse their behaviour and just say to the kid “that was naughty”. My eldest has had the same best friend since kindy, but because of “gentle parenting” on his sibling, we’ve had to limit playdates because his sibling bullies and scares both of my kids. I stepped in and intimidated the kid and told the Mum her *gentle parenting” wasn’t working and we needed a break because my kids don’t feel safe.

    Reply

  • And by not using acceptable disiplin it turns out that no one likes your child and who wants that? I always said that I wanted children that other people enjoyed being around. I would have felt like I was letting my kids down if I had turned them into horrible little brats that no one liked

    Reply

  • There is no such thing as gentle parenting – it is laziness on this parents part.

    Reply

  • It seems to be a rising trend where parents just let their kids do anything. Since a lot of people decided against smacking their kids and then realised the extra effort required with other methods of discipline, it’s like we are seeing a whole new form of parent who just lets their kids do anything all the while saying “oh, don’t do that, that’s naughty” without doing anything to back it up. The kids are walking all over them!

    Reply

  • hahahaha well said

    Reply

  • hahaha so well said!

    Reply

  • I’ve seen this happen in the playground, some parents really need to step it up if their kids are being bullies

    Reply

  • Yeah sorry but that’s not gentle parenting, that’s lazy parenting. There’s a difference.

    Reply

  • Agree. If the child is being a bully they need to be disciplined by their parents and not brushed aside

    Reply

  • Ahhhhh… I call it lazy parenting. My son was a victim of such behaviour often going back to when he was about 1 (20 years ago). Guess what? Those kids don’t grow up to be gentle, they grow up to be bullies, and sensitive children like mine have to suffer the consequences of their behaviour. It’s been a nightmare being the parent of a child who has such a lovely, kind and gentle soul watching tha tbeaten out of him time and time again as he asks why? Why is someone allowed to do that Mum without consequences? I have no answers. Sadly this is the world we live in now and it’s reflected right throughout society.

    Reply

  • I find this very frustrating too. I get told I’m too strict but I’d rather that than my kids running feral & out of control.

    Reply

  • I’ve been in a similar position where my child was being bitten. The parent didn’t even get up out of their chair!

    Reply

  • That’s shocking! I hope that child has great boundaries and the parent was just having an off day.

    Reply

  • Yeah that’s not a gentle parenting approach, that’s not using discipline at all. You can (and should) till discipline but it’s the way you do it and talk calmly rather than reacting.

    Reply

  • This isn’t gentle parenting. This is just a lazy mother. I bet you she was on her phone, not paying attention at all, or was chatting to a mum friend. There are so many parents who don’t watch their kids in these settings and it is so frustrating. Other people shouldn’t be telling your kid off!

    Reply

  • I agree. That’s not gentle parenting, it seems to be non existent parenting

    Reply

  • Yeah, that’s bad or non existent parenting.

    Reply

  • There’s gentle parenting and then there is no parenting like it seems in this case.

    Reply

Post a comment

To post a review/comment please join us or login so we can allocate your points.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join