Hello!

October 12, 2021

61 Comment

There’s so very little magic left in the world. Such small droplets of innocence floating around waiting to land on just the right sweet child. So why should I break my tween’s heart, and finally answer truthfully when he asks me, ‘Is Santa real?’

For the past three years or so, my 12-year-old has posed probing questions just as the mince tarts and tinsel start to appear on the shelves. Sometimes he’ll phrase them in an offhand way, so as not to draw too much attention to the subject.

Him: “The kids at school say Santa’s not real.”
Me: “Yeah? Which kids?” Deflect, deflect!!
Him: “Just kids.” Such a tween answer.
Me: “Well, what do you think?”
Him: “I dunno, mum. I mean, how does he get to every single house. How does he make every single toy?”
Me: “You know … it’s sad for those kids. They don’t believe. Remember, Santa’s all about believing. If you believe, the magic happens.”

It’s the same answer I give each year. A little vague and wishy washy, a whole lot of deflection riding on a wing and a prayer. But how long do I keep up the ruse?

I remember my very first Christmas as a mum. He was only nine-months-old. Way too young to remember any of what was happening. But we did the lot – Santa visit and photo, milk and cookies, snowy footprints, handwritten letter. And we’ve kept it going every years since.

But it gets me thinking, do we do all this for our kids or for ourselves?

I like to think it’s a bit of both. Yes, it makes us feel warm and fuzzy, but the reason is the joy it brings to our children. The wide-eyed surprise when they see fresh presents laid under the tree on Christmas morning. The giggles as they spot how many carrots the reindeer ate. This type of pure happiness can’t be bad, can it?

He’s now 12 years old. Right on the cusp of becoming a teen. Heading to high school next year. And with a good deal of cynicism about so many things in the world now. But this one thing, we’re still holding onto it.

I’ve had people recommend we break the news gently to him before he starts high school. For fear he’ll be ridiculed, or have his heart broken by someone who finally lays out the truth in all its innocence-shattering glory.

And then there’s his younger sibling to consider. Will he be able to help keep the secret for his little brother? Or will it come blurting out in the middle of a brotherly dust up?

Perhaps I’m holding onto the Santa secret for fear of letting go. He’s currently straddling that precarious world between still being my little boy, and becoming a man-child. It’s just one more thing I have to let go of as he grows up, and if I’m honest, it makes my heart ache for the chubby-cheeked innocence of his baby and toddler years.

My other fear is grappling with his inevitable realisation that I, as his mother, has been lying to him for his whole life. But my instinct tells me that he’s a smart kid, he’ll understand that this lie was not malicious. It wasn’t intended to deceive in a hurtful way. I hope he’ll get it.

Maybe if I do finally have ‘the talk’, he’ll be relieved. He’ll tell me that he knows. That’s he’s known for a long time, but he didn’t want to break the spell.

As Christmas creeps closer, and the questions are no doubt brewing, I’m pretty sure I’ll do what I’ve always done when it comes to mothering. I’ll just feel it.

If it feels like the right time to finally lift the lid on the truth, then so be it. And I’ll let him become part of the next stage of the journey. To become the custodian of the Santa secret for his little brother, and eventually his own children.

When do you think is the right age to let kids in on the Santa secret?

  • Yes it is appdoaching that time. I found out at 12 too, and I was pretty grateful to find out then as I was nearly a teen..I wasn’t upset at all.

    Reply

  • I told my children about St. Nicholas from the very start & explained that although he is in heaven now, his gift of giving & kindness is being continued through everyday people, dressing up as Santa & being filled with the love & spirit of St. Nick. They still get excited about Christmas & Santa coming & believed in the magic of St. Nicholas. Every time they saw a Santa, they didn’t see the man underneath the costume, they saw St. Nick.

    Reply

  • i’d love to see kids believing in Santa for a long time but the magic has to be revealed sooner or later and it might aswell come directly from you. I think as they are starting high school (if they don’t already find out before).

    Reply

  • It’s so hard to know when the time is right! My 10 and 11 year olds are quite ready to give up the illusion…only my 14 year old gets to help play Santa now and he does the Elf on a Shelf activities and pranks

    Reply

  • I think by the end of year 6, before high school. If they don’t already know, they would start questioning it a lot more and feel a little sad if all their friends knew and they didn’t.

    Reply

  • No specific age,as kids tend to work out reality a lot quicker now

    Reply

  • My daughter was told by older cousins that Santa wasn’t real. She didn’t want to believe it but when she confronted me and I told her the truth she was very upset. 🙁

    Reply

  • I just think kids eventually work it out. No need to specify an age.

    Reply

  • When they get to that age they know. It’s best not to lie.

    Reply

  • I found that most children do know this is a ruse, but are happy to go along with it because of the toys and presents they receive. And I haven’t known an older sibling to blurt out the truth either.

    Reply

  • I told my son when he was in grade 6 and before he was starting High School. He’s an only child, so it was a little bit easier to deflect, etc. And I just wanted to keep the magic alive for as long as possible. It’s just not the same without it.

    Reply

  • Keep the magic alive as long as possible…

    Reply

  • I agree with a lot of other comments why not keep the magic alive for as long as we can

    Reply

  • My 12 year old already knows he worked it out but goes along with that for my 7 year old. He also worked out tooth fairy but did not stop him putting his last tooth in water to get money lol.

    Reply

  • My 12c

    Reply

  • They get to a certain age and they just know but you keep up the pretence to keep the magic alive. I think what this Mum is doing is keeping that magic alive and it’s not hurting anyone.

    Reply

  • There really isn’t a lot of magic left in the world so I think holding on the way you have is wonderful.
    As a child I knew before I was 12 but my parents didn’t have the conversation with me until the end of primary school.

    I just don’t see it as a lie, it’s withholding the truth, yes, but you’re allowing your child to continue to have magic in their lives and a little imagination.
    Remember imagination doesn’t come as easily to teens.

    Tell him about Saint Nick, tell him that families have continued to carry on his legacy for many years to come and now he can continue to keep the Santa secret for his little brother.

    Good luck, and I hope all goes well

    Reply

  • My kids already know bout Santa. They talk about it with their friends no secrets here.

    Reply

  • I will never confirm or deny the existence of Father Christmas. Something in me still wants to believe in magic and I don’t see a reason not to.

    Reply

  • He’s 12, pretty sure he already knows Santa is fictional. My son was around 9-10, he would have conversations with his younger sister about Santa not being real, but tell me he is real because if you stop believing, you stop getting presents. But he knew the truth

    Reply

Post a comment

To post a review/comment please join us or login so we can allocate your points.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join