Mother killed her severely disabled son because of concerns over his “pedophillic tendencies”.

Kim Margaret Earle, 49, sobbed and shook as she was sentenced on Tuesday in the Brisbane Supreme Court. The court heard she was of diminished responsibility when she killed her 18-year-old son, Brandon, on the Gold Coast in 2013, reports 9 news.

Justice Roslyn Atkinson said Brandon’s interest in sadomasochism and child porn had reached the point where he wanted to kill himself following his arrest for child pornography offences and his mother couldn’t see any way out.

“Essentially, you helped him to die out of your great love for him,” Justice Roslyn Atkinson said as she sentenced Earle.

“There are not many cases where the killing is committed out of love.”

After already spending just over three years in custody, Justice Atkinson said Ms Earle had suffered enough and should be released in three months.

The court heard Ms Earle had planned to die alongside her son but had woken up from an attempted overdose and made several other unsuccessful attempts to kill herself.

She now suffers from memory loss after undergoing electric shock therapy and has to be reminded of what she has done.

Asked if she had anything to say after pleading guilty, Ms Earle spoke of her love for her son.

“I loved him very much. It was a privilege to be his mum,” she said.

When police raided their home in December 2013, he clashed violently with police and Ms Earle feared what he would do when he was released.

Nine news reports, she took a taxi to the Gold Coast University Hospital, where she worked as a nurse, donned scrubs, and stole drugs and equipment from a controlled-medication store.

After spending the night crying, she collected her son from the watchhouse and when they got home, he tried to find a knife to carry out his plan to kill himself.

That’s when she told him she could help.

Brandon wrote four pages of final words and was given a fatal overdose while lying on his bed.

Ms Earle covered his body with a sheet and placed a frangipani on top of it.

She then had her dog put down and tried to kill herself.

Ms Earle has been in custody for three years and three months, and has undergone treatment for depression and anxiety.

Justice Atkinson ordered she be released from jail on May 28 to live with her mother and sister in NSW.

“It is time you got out of custody,” Justice Atkinson said.

“You have had more than your fair share of suffering.”

If you need support or  information about suicide prevention please contact Lifeline on 13 11 14.

Share your comments below.

Image stock photo

We may get commissions for purchases made using links in this post. Learn more.
  • i can’t believe that i am reading this story as it seems like it came from an alternate universe. shock therapy, she has to be reminded of her crime, compassionate and justifiable euthanisation and a judge declaring that she should go free? i had to read this all twice and still couldn’t believe that this is real life. Wow! so she also was a nurse and knew what kind of a dosage would be fatal to a person and managed to effect this “action” on her own son but didn’t inflict herself with enough to od also. I read that he was not innocent either but this story is far out!


  • I feel compassion for this mum and in a way for her lost son as well.
    I once attended a conference on the perpetrators of sexual violence. It was very interesting. They’re surrounded by a world of misunderstanding and the system very much fails to reach out and help them.


  • What an awful situation to be in. My thoughts go out to her.


  • Oh my goodness. What a horrible situation.


  • What a horrible situation to be in. Wouldnt want to wish this upon anyone. It does sound like the Judge really did step inside the mind of the accused.


  • Electric Shock Treatment has ruined many lives. I’m not surprised Ms Earle has memory problems. The article doesn’t state the nature of his disabilties. Maybe she felt she was unable to care for him any more, especially if she needed support and was being ignored.


  • wth?? He had been arrested and should have been punished, i see it as murder and escaping punishment for him


  • A very shocking story to read for all involved.


  • Such a sad story. This mother did what she thought was right for her son and society. I’m glad the Judge was sympathetic.


Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Please enter your comment below
Would you like to include a photo?
No picture uploaded yet.
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.
Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like


Looks like this may be blocked by your browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating