Hello!

Choosing a baby name is one of the most enjoyable, yet stressful, parts of pregnancy. But one mum is asking why we have to settle on a name before we even lay eyes on our precious newborn.

Of course, not everyone names their baby before they’re born – there are plenty of parents who want to wait and see their little one before committing to a moniker. And that’s the stalemate this couple has found themselves in.

The 31-year-old mum-to-be says she and her 33-year-old husband are expecting their first baby in October.

“We don’t know if we’re having a boy or a girl because my side of the family believes that it’s bad luck to find out before the baby is born,” she explained.

“So lately my husband and I have been getting into disagreements about choosing a name. We made a short list of names that we liked a while ago, but we never made a final decision since we didn’t know the sex of the baby.

“My husband brought it up again and suggested that we pick the name we like the most, and then use the feminine or masculine version of it depending on the sex of the baby, like ‘Daniel vs Danielle’.

“I said that I still wanted to wait and see what our baby looks like so that we can pick the name that fits the best and not be stuck with a random choice.”

“My husband says that doesn’t make sense because newborn babies don’t really look like anything so it’s going to come down to a random choice anyway, and he’d rather make it ahead of time. He also said that he thinks I owe him a compromise on this one since I wouldn’t let him find out the sex of the baby ahead of time, which he wasn’t thrilled about.

“Am I the a**hole if I still want to wait until the baby is born before picking the name?”

Did you name your baby before they were born? Let us know in the comments below.

And make sure you check out the just-released list of Australia’s Top Baby Names For 2023.

We may get commissions for purchases made using links in this post. Learn more.
  • Definitely a “to each their own” I think. Do or don’t pick a name early – at the end of the day it is the parents decision only.

    Reply

  • We found out the sex of each of our Children, I liked my Son’s name for years and my Husband was on board with it, although, he did want his shortened name as our Son’s middle name but it did not flow with our Son’s name and our Surname so we agreed on a suitable middle name. When we had our Daughter we also found out that she was a girl. The names we originally had chosen for a girl when my son was born was used by a friend, so that name was out. We decided to involve our son who was 8 at the time in naming his sister. He first chose a name that was his best friend’s Sister’s name, although we like the name, we didn’t think it appropriate as we think he had a little crush on his friend’s older Sister. Lol ! The second name he chose was a very pretty name that I hadn’t even thought of and he chose her middle name as well and it is a beautiful name.

    As for not deciding to find out, this is a personal issue and it is neither right or wrong and parents should not be judged for waiting. Even though, I found out with my two children, if I had a third child, I would have waited for the surprise as I already had one of each.

    As for waiting to see your child to choose what name suits, I’m on the fence for 3 reasons. Firstly most newborns change in the first couple of months and although some keep some of their newborn features, the don’t really look the same as when they were born. Secondly, your child develops their own unique personality and any name picked will not change this. I have had a friend recently did not name her baby for over 4 weeks, which was a bit too long I think, especially, with their response to hearing their name.

    Reply

  • All 3 of my kids were born nameless and we never found out the sex before they were born. We had discussed names but never picked one until they were born. It wasn’t about what they looked like when they were born it a feeling I had when I held them. Then I chose the names.

    Reply

  • I know quite a few people who have been set on a name only to change it once the baby was actually born because the original name didn’t “suit but we named all 4 of ours before they were born.

    Reply

  • I think so what is right for you. I always new what I wanted to call my daughter so for me this was the easiest decision I made during pregnancy. I do know some friends who have waited till they met their child to decide on a name.


    • I agree, we waited and found the right names for our children when they were born.

    Reply

  • We waited and when they were born chose names that are perfect for them.
    We enjoyed being in the moment of each pregnancy and waited for each new step such as naming.

    Reply

  • We named all our kids before they were born. I tend to agree with the Dad on this one. Better to take time to think about it.

    Reply

  • Why do we have to chose a baby name before the baby is born? Because making a life changing decision on a whim is immature.

    Reply

  • I agree, we don’t have to choose a baby name before the baby is born. We picked the name of our first born 3 days after she was born.
    My parents picked the name Martine for me with as middle name Ellen. When they saw me they thought Martine didn’t suite me, but Ellen. So they decided to call me by my middle name.

    Reply

  • Waiting until you see the baby shouldn’t be an issue. Gather a list of ones you like, as many as you like and take your time when he or she is here.

    Reply

  • I think most people have a short-list and wait to meet baby! The father of the child and I had a preferred name and a short list… we ended up choosing the preferred name but nice to wait to bet bubs first. The certainly don’t all look the same!

    Reply

  • We had two names ready for each bub and then chose one the baby was born depending on which one seemed to suit more!

    Reply

  • I couldn’t decide on a name until my baby arrived, and even then it took a few days!

    Reply

  • I did have two names for my twin boys before they were born. But I know a few people who haven’t had names when the baby was born. Which is fine.

    Reply

  • We don’t have too….

    Reply

Post a comment
Add a photo
Your MoM account


Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like

Loading…

Looks like this may be blocked by your browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join