Concern we will see a growing number of unsafe freebirths due to a change in homebirthing laws over the coming years.

Figures on the number of women choosing to freebirth are not collated, but researchers and midwives believe it’s on the rise.

The change to homebirthing laws could spell the end of private homebirths in Australia, leaving women determined to homebirth with little choice but to go it alone.

Homebirth vs freebirth

Tried This? RATE IT Now…

Image of Love To Dream Transition Suit
Love To Dream Transition Suit

Submitting your rating…

Freebirth is very different to properly supervised homebirth with a registered midwife.

For many free birthers, this also means no check-ups, no ultrasounds, no midwife appointments at all.

The change to homebirth laws

In 2019, private homebirths in Australia may come to an end altogether.

Only one company, MIGA, offers insurance to private homebirth midwives in Australia, and that cover does not include the most high-risk period — labour, reports ABC NEWS.

The Federal Government provided an exemption in 2010 that allows midwives to attend homebirths despite being uninsured during labour, but that exemption expires in December 2019.

Without it, private midwives would be committing an illegal act by conducting a homebirth while uninsured.

Professor of Midwifery at the University of Western Sydney Hannah Dahlen describes women like Natalie as “refugees from the mainstream maternity care”, and says their stories reveal a deeper malaise within the system.

She and her colleagues are researching the impact of birth trauma and the connection to subsequent freebirths or high-risk homebirths.

“We are in a situation where I’ve probably never been so concerned as I am now,” Professor Dahlen said.

“Our research is showing us freebirth is rising, the use of [unregulated] birth workers is rising. Women just can’t access midwives — if they can access them, they can’t afford them.”

Professor Dahlen said unless a solution to the insurance problem was found urgently, more private midwives would stop practicing.

“So in December 2019 when the exemption for insurance expires, there is a real potential that women will not be able to access a registered midwife for their homebirth,” she said.

“So they will turn to [unregulated] birth workers or they will turn to doing it themselves and that is a real concern.”

Professor Dahlen said a lack of insurance was just one of a number of factors causing private midwives to leave practice.

She said in the past five years, the number of private midwives had more than halved to about 100.

In that same time, Professor Dahlen said about half of all private midwives had been reported to the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA).

“The current climate for private midwives in Australia, I think, is toxic,” she said.

“I think there’s a witch-hunt going on that doesn’t involve fire, but involves an incredible amount of trauma.”

Gino Pecoraro from the Australian Medical Association cautioned women against the practice and said the safest place for women to give birth was in a hospital.

Liz Wilkes from Midwives Australia said midwives were trained to respond if something went wrong.

“We can see very subtle changes in birth … but if you’re birthing by yourself then the chances are that those subtle changes won’t be picked up in a period where appropriate action can be taken,” she said.

“I do agree that it is their body and they do have the right to choose and I understand that they are very well-educated women, generally speaking.

“It is a very normal life event for most people, but when it goes wrong unfortunately it can go quite badly wrong … they often don’t know what they don’t know.
Read more: The latest birthing trend encourages women to get back to nature and birth unhindered and unaided.

Share your comments below

  • nope i could not do that! i get anxious about how bub is doing so i had to know everything! it sucks having to wait to see someone at the hospital but worth it to get peace of mind


  • Its such a huge risk. I just don’t see hospitals as the enemy.


  • So many mums and babies lost that we never considered it. Medicine has come a long way to help us all but people seem to want to fight it.


  • Home birth was never a thought or option for the birth of our children.


  • I wonder why the homebirthing laws are changing and there is such a insurance problem ?! Don’t get me wring, I’m all for homebirth when possible, but professional care and supervision before, during and after birth is so important.


  • Some Mums want to go back to the 1800s and early 1900s. Do they realise how many stillbirths or babies who only lived for a few days. Unfortunately the numbers were high. I have relatives that in one family alone lost 3 babies and another family lost 2. There is plenty of good hospitals now. Back then there was very few and too far to travel. It could easily take you a day to get to the closest one…..by horse and cart.


  • Each to their own but a hospital is a safer option just in case something does go wrong.


  • This is quite scary. We might also see a rise in the number of still births and other complications too… hospitals are there for a reason.


Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Please enter your comment below
Would you like to include a photo?
No picture uploaded yet.
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.
Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like


Looks like this may be blocked by you browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating