Mum shamed for refusing to contribute to expensive Christmas gift for her child’s Kindergarten teacher.

The NSW mum claims now when she does school pick-up she feels judgment coming from other parents. She sees mum’s she once considered close friends standing on the other side of the playground, blatantly ignoring her.

She is also concerned of the conflict affecting her son — that the six-year-old will stop being invited to birthday parties and playdates.

The mum decided not to give money to send her son’s kindergarten teacher for a gourmet weekend away at a winery for Christmas.

“It seemed very excessive to give teachers such expensive presents, so I said no,” Sophie tells Kidspot.

“There is all this pressure on parents to come up with the perfect gift — or spend a lot of money.”

She received a Facebook message in October asking parents to give money for a weekend away for the kindergarten teacher and her partner which involves a three-course fine dining meal.

“I’m surprised I’m in the minority of people who think this is not normal, the majority of people are just going along with it,” she says.

“I’m just absolutely gobsmacked this is a thing in school now.”

“It’s just crazy,” she says. “I’ve never experienced anything like this before. I don’t know whether we are competing to be seen to be good parents or whether they don’t want to miss out because of the peer pressure.”

“I think that teachers will then favour people who have given them expensive presents,” she says.

“It is more competitive now, where people want the best for their child in that they want that extra attention from the teacher and the way to do that is buying gifts.”

“If you give it to one teacher one year then you’ve got to do it for the whole of their school life — and that gets really expensive for parents,” she says.

“I know the teachers work hard but I don’t think they deserve a $500 pamper pack at a spa.

“I know people who are doing it just to be in the group, to be included, but I’d like to think I’m being a role model for my son.”

“I’m not going to give in to the peer pressure,” she says.

“Putting in big wads of cash is not giving him that experience — that joy of giving — so we got a little gift that he picked, that he can wrap and he can give to the teacher himself.

“It shouldn’t be the expectation that they get expensive gifts every year.”

I actually thought it was illegal for teachers to accept expensive gifts?

Info about receiving gifts via NSW Education

“Accepting gifts and other benefits has the potential to compromise your position by creating a sense of obligation and undermining your impartiality. It may also affect the reputation of the Department and its officers. You must not create the impression that any person or organisation is influencing the Department or the decisions of any of its employees.

“Always consider the value and purpose of a gift or benefit before making any decision about accepting it. A gift that is more than nominal value ($50) must not become personal property. You should either politely refuse it or advise the contributor that you will accept it on behalf of your school or workplace.

“When such a gift is accepted, you must advise your manager or Principal. They will determine how it should be treated and make a record of its receipt. Depending on the nature and value of the gift, it may be appropriate to record the gift in the asset register as a donation or other such record established for that purpose.”

Last year we were advised by our school that gift vouchers were not to be accepted under any circumstances.

teachers-gifts

Department of Education TAS policy issued in November 2016 states,

Officers and employees should not expect to receive gifts, benefits or hospitality for doing a job they are paid by the public to do. In most situations, ‘thanks’ is enough.

You must never accept a gift, benefit or hospitality, token memento or modest refreshment in the following circumstances:
• It is money or money equivalent;
• A valuable object valued at $100 AUD or higher;
• You are a Government buyer and your acceptance may influence or be perceived to influence a procurement or disposal decision;
• You or your agency makes decisions or gives advice regarding the gift giver or are likely to in future and your acceptance may influence or be perceived to influence the decision or advice;
• Your acceptance may otherwise cause an actual, perceived or potential conflict of interest, or may be seen by other people as a reward or incentive.

Officers and employees should not expect to receive gifts, benefits or hospitality for doing a job they are paid by the public to do. In most situations, officers and employees should refuse gifts, benefits or hospitality if offered.

Read more on that here.

Do you think the gift is too much?  

Share your comments below

  • I wonder how much each parent chipped in. They were probably more upset because they had to pay more themselves to make up for her share. I worry too about my child not being invited to things because the parents don’t like me. It’s unfair and shouldn’t happen. Not allowing a child to a party because you don’t like their parent is selfish if your child wants them to come.

    Reply

  • Very excessive. Good on her for standing her ground.
    There is a school near my house where all the mums compete against each other from gifts for teachers to designer hands bags.
    Needless to say we are avoiding that school for enrolment.

    Reply

  • I think gift giving for Teachers is absolutely getting out of hand. We did gifts early on at primary school but then it dropped off. I think it’s now ridiculous. Something small and thoughtful is all that should be necessary.

    Reply

  • I know a teacher who reckoned the best gift she ever received was a posy made from flowers grown in the pupil’s own little garden plot

    Reply

  • I also agree the gift is excessive, contribute what you can I say. Also, we are already spending large amounts of money to give our children a good education. Money here, money there, it just becomes greedy and crazy.

    Reply

  • Teachers shouldn’t expect expensive gifts. All children should be treated equal and as some families don’t have money to spare the gift should be a token from the child. Working in a hospital you’re not allowed to accept anything for yourself, it has to be shared with all the staff.

    Reply

  • That seems to be a very expensive gift to give… Not everyone can also afford gifts like that…its the though that counts not the amount we spend on a present

    Reply

  • Looks like she was smart because the teacher won’t be able to accept the gift anyway.

    Reply

  • I think a holiday might be excessive and inappropriate for children to give to their teacher.
    Last year we started to buy the teachers a Christmas ornament each. And will be doing that for future years.
    It’s just a sign of appreciation that you acknowledge all the hard work the teacher does for your child

    Reply

  • I applaud this mum for sticking up for her beliefs, I do think it is excessive, and the other mothers are not worth knowing if they judge her for this, how crazy can people be, for goodness sake, I think mums have enough on their plate to worry about such superficial people, Herd mentality here I think.

    Reply

  • I have a lot of friends whom are teachers and they all agree that their favorite present is something from the child. Monitory gifts are not a requirement, a small token of appreciation is more than enough. They said that they didn’t get into teaching for the end of year gift.

    Reply

  • I think it’s personal on what you decide with given a gift at Christmas. I definitely wouldn’t give money for the teacher to have a weekend away that is very unnecessary. If I was a teacher and received a card of my students I would be so happy xxx

    Reply

  • Surely parents could just donate the amount they wished? That would be fairer?

    Reply

  • Not everyone is in the position to make a donation toward a gift. Especially at Christmas

    Reply

  • I think all gifts are unnecessary. In the case of a teacher 30 or 60 or 90 ‘small gifts’ add up to a lot of trash for the op shop (or sugar in someone’s life!) I especially do not like those situations where it is ‘compulsory’ to contribute… in my case but a coach who is doing it voluntarily but we get sent emails from the ‘organizer’ asking for a fixed amount of money by a certain date as a ‘gift’. Way too much pressure..

    Reply

Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Please enter your comment below
Would you like to include a photo?

No picture uploaded yet
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.

Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like

Loading…

Looks like this may be blocked by you browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join