Hello!

A while back on our facebook page, one of our mums shared that she was a nanny and wondered if she should provide Christmas gifts for each of her little charges.  The conversation that followed was lovely and constructive … well, mostly.

Not surprisingly there was one mum who clearly felt justified passing a value judgement on mums who have nannies.

The comment went on to say that “as [her child’s] mother it is my responsibility to raise, educate, love and nurture my child, not someone else’s” assuming that mums who have a nanny are clearly not interested in their children and would rather be out doing anything other than raising their children.

A little soapbox moment if I may to those who think nannies are for the rich ‘n’ famous and who the hell has one?

Let’s have a look at the situation and address some of the myths.

1. A mother should be the one to raise, educate, nurture and provide for their children.

There are two assumptions at play here.

The first being that all mums who work do so as their preference rather than as a requirement.

If you are able to care for your children full-time, you’re very lucky that you don’t need to work.  You must be in a financial situation where you’re able to stay at home and still cover all your costs.  Well done you.  You either have no mortgage, have saved shedloads pre-baby so that you can stay home for a long time, have a very understanding employer who offers paid maternity leave for a very long period of time or you have a partner who is able to provide financially for all of you.   Or you’ve inherited money along the way or you’ve just sold a business you created for a motza and are now rolling in cash. So you have the choice as to whether or not it will be you that is the full-time carer for your child.

Please don’t assume that every mum who leaves their children in the care of another (whether it be short day care, occasional day care, long day care, with a family member or with a nanny) does so by choice.  99.9% of us are NOT meeting girlfriends at the gym, grabbing a coffee, popping in for a pedicure and then having our botox topped up for the month and frankly can’t be bothered to raise our children.  Most of us leave our children with a carer in order to go to work so that we can provide for our families; a better now, a roof over their heads, healthy meals and opportunities by way of the experiences we’re able to give them.

The second assumption is that we would all be better mums if we stayed at home full-time to raise and nurture our children.

Whilst lots of mums assume that all they’ve ever wanted to do is to stay at home and raise their children, the reality is often quite different.  Whether it’s their personalities, their children’s personalities or another factor of their personal situation, some mums just feel better within themselves if they are doing some work outside the home.  And we all know only too well that when we are happy within ourselves, we are able to be much better mums.  So this assumption is flawed and the fact is that some mums are better mums if they’re able to have time away from home to recharge and then come back in ready to give everything they have to being a great mum.

2. Nannies are for the rich and famous

If you read “Nanny Diaries” (and subscribe to that as truth) you could be forgiven for thinking that nannies are for the rich ‘n’ famous. The reality however is that nannies are often a very good option for those mums who have to work (and are far from Carrie Bradshaw).  I am a mum who needs to work and am definitely not rich ‘n’ famous – let me assure you!  What I have discovered is that the cost of a nanny was either line ball or cheaper than long day care with other side benefits.  Here’s the numbers for a mum of 3 kids under school age who has to work and needs long daycare:  Child 1 (5 years) is $125 per day, Child 2 (3 years) is $135 per day, Child 3 (1 year) is $145 per day.  Now this is Sydney so it might be cheaper if you live somewhere else – but probably not drastically.  All up that is $405 per day.

3. Nannies Cost A Fortune

We paid our nanny $25 per hour so for all the kids that’s $200 per 8 hour day – the children get to wake up when they’re ready, be at home for their sleeps, splash in the blow up pool, go on fun outings on the ferry, go to their ballet lesson and toddle off to playgroup and the park.  Our nanny would even have their friends over during the day to help out other mum friends of mine. And then at the end of the day, they would have dinner, a lovely big bath and be in their PJs ready for cuddles and stories when I finished work at 5.00pm.  I’d come straight home rather than having to pick up from childcare and bring them home tired, hungry and without a bath.  Made for much happier family all ’round.

Even if you deduct the government rebate (still over $200 per day for all three kids), it’s still cheaper.  And guess what?  While the kids were napping, our nanny would pop on some washing, throw the broom through the house and do a bit of ironing.  Unlike lots of lucky mums whose parents look after their kids for free, we have no family anywhere nearby so every minute of care is paid for.

Getting a ‘nanny’ was logical – we did the sums before we made a decision.

It Worked For Us

I did this for 2 – 3 days a week for years and it worked for us.  I still took them to swimming lessons, gymnastics, music lessons and I cook all their meals. And while our nanny was there …. I certainly wasn’t lunching, at the gym or having mani’s … I was working. Don’t take this personally but it does sound as though you’re making a value judgement on mums who have ‘nannies’ and assuming they’d rather be off being rich ‘n famous and leaving the raising of our children to the help.  This is not Nanny Diaries we’re talking about – just a workable solution for lots of mums.

If the definition of a loving, caring nurturing mum can only be delivered if you’re at home with them 24/7, well I guess I’m falling short as a mum.

Now’s the time to weigh in on the debate. What do you think? Share your thoughts by commenting today …

Much MoM Love,

This post written by Nikki Hills, Mum of 4 and Founder of Mouths of Mums®. Nikki has worked in marketing, advertising and communications for close to 20 years and created Mouths of Mums® to give real mums a space to connect and trial and review products for free. Mouths of Mums® was also founded to give brands the opportunity to connect with real mums and truly understand what they need to do in order to deliver products that meet mums’ needs and will therefore be embraced by real mums.

You can also follow Mouths of Mums (& Nikki) on facebook – there’s always so much happening!

 

  • I know that I am a much better mother when I get time away from the kids, so hatever works for each individual person.

    Reply

  • No need to justify your choices to anyone. There are always going to be those judge,entail people and if we keep justifying ourselves to the,
    M, our whole l Fe will be a justification. So just keep on keeping on I say!

    Reply

  • I dont see having a nanny as any different to child dare other than your child remains in the comfort of their own home!

    Reply

  • Having a Nanny sounds like a perfect idea, especially when you have a few kiddos! Our daycare is $450 a week after rebates and we aren’t even earning high wages, so dread to think what it would cost for a couple of kids.

    Reply

  • We had no choice but for both of us to work just to pay the bills and feed the family. Living in our small country town we didn’t have day-care so I had a babysitter. To me it was so much better because they got more one on one time. I would have got a Nanny if there was one available though

    Reply

  • If you can afford it and you need to go back to work or do other things, great! I can definitely see the economics of it in place of paying for childcare for 2+ kids.

    Reply

  • People normally get nannys so they can work not because they have a lot of money.

    Reply

  • You know what works you the best.

    Reply

  • Wow being a nanny sounds hard work! This is a personal choice and both options have pros and cons. My only concern would be finding someone i trusted to leave alone with my kids.
    I totally agree that time away home helps mum be better parents and allows them to come in fresh. I’m a sahm and would love the opportunity to get out of the house now and again on my own for something other than groceries. My husband does great at providing for us and works super hard. We can’t stretch to cover childcare so it would have to come out of my pay if I got a job, not many opportunities for full or part time work that pay well enough for cover the cost of a nanny at $200 per day or centre fees. Like many current working mums I’d end up working just to pay childcare and work expenses like travel, clothes (my current wardrobe is definitely not professional) etc.
    I know a nanny from my child’s kinder and she seems great and often picks up her charge’s friend in the afternoon.

    Reply

  • A nanny sounds like a great option! All depends on your circumstances

    Reply

  • Having worked as a nanny – I’ve found for families with 2 or 3 under school age children then a nanny works out a lot cheaper. (And definitely so for more than 3 children) And much more convenient too with the children being in their own home, own beds for naps and with a routine they’re familiar with. Also I used to do little tasks like putting washing on, folding kids clothes, kids meals and some simple cleaning such as benches, vacuuming floors etc when had the time.

    It’s really what suits each family – no one should be judging others wether they stay at home, use childcare or use a nanny. Each to their own and each to what works for that family.

    Reply

  • If it works for you, why not.

    Reply

  • Whatever works for you. As long as the kids are looked after why does it matter.

    Reply

  • I think it is great if you can do it. Lots of kids at the local State school have nannies. It is more personal care then childcare.

    Reply

  • I think for some families it is a great option and works well. Financial, if you have a few kids, it works out much cheaper than day care. All families are different, so what works well for one may not work well for others. It depends on each family’s circumstances.


    • Yes that’s true, it may well be cheaper than daycare when you’ve several kids. Although in our case, we get 84% back from centerlink for daycare for our youngest two

    Reply

Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Please enter your comment below
Would you like to include a photo?
No picture uploaded yet.
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.
Your MoM account


Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like

Loading…

Looks like this may be blocked by you browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating
Join