A pricey Australian children’s car seat has dramatically failed a crash test and ejected a dummy in what could be a fatal blow in a real-life car accident.

This is actually the first time a crash test dummy has been forcibly ejected in more than 25 years of crash tests performed by the independent not-for-profit Child Restraint Evaluation Program (CREP).

The concerning test showed the straps of the car seat releasing on impact in a crash at 56km/h, with the dummy flying head over heels and somersaulting in mid-air.

Catastrophic Test

The car seat that failed the test is the Joie I-Travvel Car Seat, priced at $629 and had been secured in the forward facing position, using ISOFIX – which is an alternative way of securing a child restraint without using a seatbelt.

Even when secured by a seatbelt, this particular car seat scored one star in forward-facing mode, but the dummy was not flung out of the seat.  In rear-facing mode, the seat scored four stars in the CREP testing.

The CREP program tests the safety of car seats when placed under more rigorous real-life conditions, including impact at 56km/h.

Australian standards test car seats at an impact of 49km/h and under these conditions, the Joie I-Travvel Car Seat meets the basic requirements for safety.


NRMA’s road safety expert, Dimitra Vlahomitros, said a child restraint that doesn’t secure a dummy just doesn’t cut it, as reported in Sydney Morning Herald.

The results were unprecedented, shocking and the outcome could be catastrophic, she said.

“This is the first time a restraint failed to the extent that the dummy was ejected. Choosing the correct child seat could be a lifesaving decision so it is critical parents make their purchase based on performance and ease of use rather than price or aesthetics.

Would My Child Survive?

“Any parent looking at the footage of a crash test wouldn’t have any comfort that a child would be restrained and survive a crash. That’s what parents demand: That a restraint should restrain a child and save his or her life,” Ms Vlahomitros said.

“These tests demonstrate once again that not all car seats are created equal and the manufacturer needs to lift its game.”

The main concern is that those parents who had bought the Joie car seat for use in rear-facing mode, when it was first launched last April, will now be considering turning the child around to forward-facing mode.

Joie I-Travvel Car Seat fails safety test

Zero Rating

The shocking results of this test instigated CREP to introduce a zero rating. The organisation has also notified the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) and Standards Australia.

Deeply Troubled

The manufacturer of Joie Baby products, Bright Children’s Products Co Limited, said that it “was deeply troubled by the CREP result”.

“The safety and well-being of our customers and their children is paramount to Joie Baby, and we are thoroughly reviewing the results as a matter of utmost urgency to understand the results fully and what further action may be taken,” the company said in a statement.

They did add that the children’s car seat complied with the Australian/New Zealand Standard for child restraints (AS/NZS 1754), which was widely considered to be among the most demanding in the world.

The Joie i-Gemm Infant Capsules, manufactured by the same company, was recalled late last year as its top tether strap was liable to release under excessive load, potentially injuring a child.

Find more details about the crash test ratings for car seats at www.childcarseats.com.au

Joie’s consumer hotline can be reached on (02) 8197 9962 Monday to Friday 8am-4pm AEST.

Would you be concerned about the results of this car seat test? Tell us in the comments below.

  • Thankful that these seats and tested and scrutinised well


  • It’s so good that things get tested so rigorously but a bit scarey to see results when things go wrong. Even scarier that it was on the market before the faults were realised


  • Very scary


  • That is deeply troubling! How did it get to customers to buy!?


  • How was this able to go onto shelves?


  • H wow that’s scary, is this particular seat out in the market or is this a new one yet to come on market and the are suggested a RRP of $649?

    If they are it I’m sure there would be an urgent recall on all these seats yea?


  • Scary stuff. I hope there aren’t many people out there with this seat.


  • Scary stuff especially if you have one of those seats.


  • When I had a car accident I had my youngest with me and he was 11 months old. I ended up worse than him because of his car seat. The police kept it on display in their station. My son stayed in hospital only because I had to. It was a safe-and-sound car seat and it saved his life.


  • I thought there were stricter rules??


  • At least it’s getting tested now


  • Terrifying to hear this, especially if you own one.
    How did it pass previous tests to get placed on the market initially?


  • Curious as to how this initially passed any testing. I thought there were such strict guidelines on testing, but clearly not.


  • Never heard of this product but I would bring it back and demand a refund that’s for sure especially when spending $600 it’s not cheap!


  • So what happens if you purchased one of these car seats last april? Obviously you wouldnt want to be using it anymore but do you still get a refund from baby bunting?


Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Please enter your comment below
Would you like to include a photo?
No picture uploaded yet.
Please wait to see your image preview here before hitting the submit button.
Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like


Looks like this may be blocked by you browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating