A Melbourne school for children with intellectual disabilities is under investigation after being accused of making one of its students sit outside in a beanbag.

The child sat there for more than an entire term as a way of dealing with his challenging behaviour.

A former teacher at the Merriang Special Development School spoke to ABCs 7.30 report on condition of anonymity.

“I don’t know how you can call yourself a teacher if that’s what you’re doing with a kid every day,” John (not his real name) said.

He said he discovered the practice when he returned from long service leave and spoke to other staff members.

“They had said that he’d been in the yard for the entirety of term three,” he said.

“And I said, what do you mean for the entirety of term three? They said, he’d come in in the morning and he would go outside, and he’d sit there for the six hours of the school day.”

“Sometimes he would walk around the yard, but very rarely. Mostly just sitting on the beanbag — he might have had an iPad at times.”

This had been going on for all of Term 3 and some of Term 4.

“Term 3, that’s winter,” John said.

“It just seemed so wrong that in 2015 in a suburb in Melbourne where we’re in a … five-year-old school where everyone’s supposedly doing a good job, that that was the best solution that they could come up with addressing his behavioural needs.”

John says a fellow teacher told him she documented the student’s treatment in her work program.

“And I said, what is management saying about this? And she said that’s their way of treating it, and I’m not going to rock the boat.”

The boy’s mother was unaware that her son was constantly sitting outside at school.

She only found out from a teacher, not John, and another aide during the last week of the school year.

“It was the talk of the school, but I found out too late,” she said.

“It just shouldn’t be happening. It shouldn’t have happened. How many other kids has it happened to? How many will it happen to?

“And they just act like there’s nothing wrong with it. Like it’s OK. It’s not OK.”

Victorian Education Minister James Merlino said the allegations were “concerning” and said he had asked his department to commission an independent review of the matter.

“All students, including those with special needs, should have access to fair, safe and inclusive schools,” he said.

A statement from the Education Department outlined the school’s position but said all complaints were taken seriously.

“As part of his behaviour support plan, the student could access a quiet and calm space outside the classroom when he needed time away from the rest of the class. This space was in clear sight and able to be monitored by staff at all times,” he said.

“The school became concerned that the student was withdrawing from educational activities too frequently and appointed a full-time dedicated education support worker in term four to work one-on-one with the student, leading to improved engagement with educational and social activities.”

“The Department takes any issues raised about students with disabilities in its care very seriously and will commission an independent review into the details of this incident.”

How would you react if this was your child?

Share your comments below.

Image via shutterstock

We may get commissions for purchases made using links in this post. Learn more.
  • A child may like some time away from the noise of others but surely are safe quite areas within the buildings. The school either needs more support staff or some are guilty of neglect.


  • I would be gutted when this was my child.
    I’m sure they could have used an quiet room or office to work one on one with this child !
    I know for one thing that I’ll check on the school when my girlie with a disability will go to school.


  • Engagement of a staff member should of been done sooner.. So should of the parent been told of the situation so they can help with a solution.. Mainly due to the fact the parents think the child is in a education centre Not a childs daycare(infant) provider…


  • This is unbelievable – should never have happened and certainly not in winter.


  • I would go mental. You place your child every day in the hands of so called professionals and they do this to him! Words fail me. Each child deserves attention and care. There should definitely be an inquire into this school.


  • Schools are very bad t dealing with kids with disabilities.


  • Incredible! But did the parents know about it? No other parent saw this boy sitting there?
    I hope the Police will investigate this school very thoroughly!
    I would be so mad if that was my child!!


  • A shocking story,imagine if that was your child!


  • This is beyond rude! This is a school for children with disabilities! They should have had more training!


  • I don’t understand why he wasn’t inside under the supervision of an aide. Why outside? Why wasn’t his mother/father informed?


  • People who are on the autism spectrum do have their difficult times and do need their own time out to help with the sensory over loads BUT they are at a specialist school with trained professionals, this poor child is there to be educated in what ever form is possible not being left outside constantly.


  • What a horrible way to treat a child with a disability. You as a teacher chose to work at that school and should know the right and wrong way to treat a child.


Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Add a photo
Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like


Looks like this may be blocked by your browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating