There’s a whole cult of passionate pie makers who use their beloved kitchen appliance to make all kind of dishes, which are definitely not pies. Pie Maker groups are packed with photos of pie maker cupcakes, muffins, ‘snow cakes’, quiche and more.

But I thought why should I restrict myself only to the pie maker? How about the humble toasted sandwich (otherwise known as the jaffle) maker? I reckon this simple kitchen appliance can do much loftier things than we give it credit for. So I thought I would put it to the test.

Let’s Try…Jaffle Cakes

My first attempt was cookies and cream pillow ‘sandwich maker’ cakes. I’m not usually a box-cake person – in fact, I don’t think I’ve ever used a box cake before. It’s not like I have anything against convenience cake – it’s just that I love baking – stirring, kneading, pouring, it’s all so therapeutic for me – so I’ve just never felt the need to use a box. But I happened to spot a Greens cookies and cream cupcake kit at Aldi for really cheap the other day and thought why not?

Toasted sandwich maker cakes with batter

I then went down to the garage to haul out our el-cheapo Kmart $7 toasted sanger machine from our storage boxes but you really don’t want to know what I found when I opened it up. Yuck – let’s just say it was growing a whole city of mould on its metal plates. That went straight into the bin and I took off to Target where I bought a Sunbeam “Big One’ Sandwich Maker for $39 – way more than I wanted to spend but I figured if the cakes didn’t work out, at least I could make deep dish mega toasties with my new purchase.

I first seasoned the sandwich maker with butter and almost burnt the house down when I forgot to remove the plastic lining inside the machine. Yikes! So after I peeled off specks of burnt plastic from the plates, I was ready to begin baking.

I followed the instructions at the back of the box to mix up the batter. I opened the jaffle machine and spooned in the batter. I figured there are two ways to prepare a toasted sandwich maker cake:

Go Big

1) You can go big and fill the entire two squares with batter. This way you would have cake resembling a piece of toast, which you could then separate into halves once cooked.

Small Triangles

2) Go smaller and fill only the triangle shapes – which will produce smaller sized cakes.

I opted for the second option, added the batter and turned on the machine, closed it and waited.

I opened the machine after 4 minutes and gave the cakes a quick flip – careful they’re hot – so use a spatula or fish slice.

Toasted sandwich maker cakes cooked in a jaffle maker

After another 3 minutes, I used a skewer to check the doneness of the cakes and once the skewer came out clean, I knew they were ready.

The cakes came out easily and I let them cool before preparing the icing included in the kit to frost my cakes. I then topped off my treat with crumbled Oreos.

toasted sandwich maker cake triangles

Thumbs Up…Or Down?

And then it was the moment of truth….

I was a bit apprehensive to try the cakes but they were absolutely delicious! Moist, chocolatey and dreamy. The exterior was slightly crunchy while the inside had the perfect crumb. So yum!

The kids thought the shape of the cakes was very weird but once they got over this, they finished them off enthusiastically.

toasted sandwich maker cake showing crumbs and inside of cake

What’s Next?

A whole world of cooking creativity has just opened up. I can’t wait to try out more sandwich maker concoctions. Perhaps quiche or pikelets will be next. Or maybe sandwich maker bread or omelettes or how about a nutella stuffed puff pastry jaffle. Oooohhhh…I can’t wait!

Would you be keen to try a jaffle cake? Tell us in the comments below.

More on Mouths of Mums

New Kmart Family Size Pie Maker Is Here!

How To Make The Perfect Pie Maker Doughnuts

Viral Cooking Disaster, “Don’t Cook This in Your Pie Maker!”

Yikes! X-Rated Typo on Kmart Appliance Gave Us The Giggles

How to Make Perfect Bread Rolls in a Pie Maker

Has the Pie Maker Craze Gone Too Far?

We may get commissions for purchases made using links in this post. Learn more.
  • Wow, so many people are using cake batter in these things, I will need to get mine from my mum’s house and try it out.
    I have a golden Gaytime cake mix that’s been sitting in my cupboard for ages now!


  • They look and sound delicious, I have never thought of doing this with a sandwich maker.


  • I have one. But never thought about this.


  • I don’t have a sandwich maker any more, I now have a sandwich press so I won’t be making them any time soon. Another clever idea from another clever Mum


  • I’m not a box cake person and find them extremely unhealthy


  • They look great but I don’t have an old school sandwich press:(


  • I love this jaffle maker. We had this one growing up. It allows you to put a decent amount of filling inside. Had never considered it for this though.


  • All these clever cooks out there – if I have a cookware item I only seem to make that one item and I have enormous respect for those who are so creative to do things like this.


  • I think that’s weird ????


  • Mmmmmm looks yummy. Not sure I still have my jaffle maker though


  • very good! That looks so clever


  • This looks really yummy, and sounds like a super quick hack for when you have that cake craving!!


  • No I wouldn’t try this. It’s not difficult to bake a cake or cupcakes in the oven and I’m all about making things look pretty and edible. This does not


  • I have a toasted sandwich maker that doesn’t get much use, but im not sure im sold on the packet cake mix. There aren’t many edible ones on the shelves


  • I’ll give it a try! Why not!


Post a comment
Like Facebook page

LIKE MoM on Facebook

Add a photo
Your MoM account

Lost your password?

Enter your email and a password below to post your comment and join MoM:

You May Like


Looks like this may be blocked by your browser or content filtering.

↥ Back to top

Thanks For Your Star Rating!

Would you like to add a written rating or just a star rating?

Write A Rating Just A Star Rating